-
What do we mean by setbacks and adversity?
-
Why is it important to focus on setbacks and adversity?
-
When should you work to address setbacks and adversity?
-
How do you, as a leader, respond to setbacks and adversity?
Every community organization experiences disruptions, disappointments, uncertainty, and difficult conditions.
Funding may change. A program may fail to produce the expected results. A key employee may leave. A public controversy may develop. Technology may fail. Community needs may change. A natural disaster, public-health emergency, policy change, or economic disruption may affect the organization's ability to operate.
Leadership matters in these situations, but responding well is not a test of whether one person can remain endlessly optimistic or solve everything alone.
Effective response depends on leadership, governance, staff, volunteers, community relationships, plans, systems, financial capacity, and the organization's ability to learn and adapt.
This section discusses how leaders and organizations can respond to both discrete setbacks and longer-running adverse conditions while protecting people, maintaining essential work, communicating honestly, and adapting when circumstances require change.
What do we mean by setbacks and adversity?
It can be useful to distinguish between a setback and an adverse condition, although the categories can overlap.
Setbacks
A setback is a discrete event or series of events that interferes with progress or creates an unexpected problem.
Examples might include:
- A major grant is not renewed
- A key employee leaves unexpectedly
- An evaluation shows that a program is not producing the intended results
- A technology failure interrupts services
- A partner withdraws from an important project
- A public report contains inaccurate information about the organization
- Severe weather damages a facility
Some setbacks can be addressed relatively quickly. Others have consequences that continue for months or years.
The first task is to understand what happened, what is at risk, what must be addressed immediately, and what can wait.
Adversity
Adversity is a difficult condition that persists over time or repeatedly creates barriers to the organization's work.
Examples might include:
- Chronic funding instability
- Persistent staffing shortages
- Long-term community or political opposition
- Ongoing difficulty reaching people who need services
- Repeated technology or infrastructure problems
- A prolonged economic downturn
- Unresolved organizational conflict
- A continuing policy or regulatory environment that restricts the work
Chronic adverse conditions usually require more than one corrective action.
They may require changes in strategy, funding, staffing, partnerships, service delivery, organizational structure, or expectations about what the organization can realistically accomplish.
A discrete setback can become a long-term adverse condition. A chronic adverse condition can also generate sudden setbacks.
The distinction is useful mainly because different situations require different responses.
Why is it important to focus on setbacks and adversity?
Difficult conditions can affect much more than one program or project.
To protect people and maintain essential functions
During disruption, the first priority may not be growth or even ordinary productivity.
It may be:
- Protecting safety
- Maintaining essential services
- Meeting payroll or other immediate obligations
- Preserving important records and systems
- Communicating with participants and partners
- Preventing additional harm
Organizations should know which functions are essential and what people, technology, facilities, vendors, information, and authority those functions depend on.
To make better decisions under uncertainty
Stress and urgency can encourage people to act before they understand the situation.
Leaders need enough structure to distinguish:
- What is known
- What is still uncertain
- What requires immediate action
- What requires additional information
- What decisions can be changed later
- What decisions would be difficult to reverse
The goal is not to eliminate uncertainty before acting. That may be impossible.
The goal is to make uncertainty visible and manage it responsibly.
To sustain trustworthiness
People watch how an organization communicates and acts when conditions are difficult.
Trustworthiness depends on:
- Accurate information
- Honest acknowledgment of uncertainty
- Appropriate transparency
- Follow-through
- Fair decision processes
- Protecting confidentiality
- Correcting mistakes
An organization does not need to appear invulnerable in order to remain credible.
To protect staff and volunteer capacity
Difficult periods may increase workload, uncertainty, emotional strain, and pressure on staff and volunteers.
An organization cannot sustain services indefinitely by asking people to work harder, remain constantly available, or absorb responsibilities that should be addressed through staffing and planning.
Pay attention to:
- Workload
- Scheduling
- Rest and leave
- Backup coverage
- Supervision
- Psychological and physical safety
- Access to appropriate support
To learn and reduce future vulnerability
A setback may reveal:
- A weak financial control
- An undocumented process
- Excessive dependence on one person
- A technology vulnerability
- A communication problem
- An unrealistic assumption
- A gap in training
- A partner or vendor dependency
The event itself is not valuable simply because it caused hardship.
The value comes from examining what happened and using what was learned to reduce future risk.
To determine whether the organization should restore, adapt, or change direction
Not every setback should be answered by returning to exactly what existed before.
Sometimes recovery means restoring an effective process.
Sometimes it means changing how the organization works.
And sometimes new conditions reveal that a program, strategy, partnership, or organizational structure is no longer sustainable.
When should you work to address setbacks and adversity?
The appropriate timing depends on urgency, safety, uncertainty, and the consequences of delay.
Setbacks
A setback may require immediate action, but not every setback requires an immediate final solution.
First determine whether the organization needs to:
- Protect people
- Stop an ongoing loss or unsafe activity
- Maintain essential services
- Preserve information or evidence
- Notify responsible people
- Correct inaccurate public information
- Obtain legal, financial, technical, or professional advice
Once the immediate situation is stable, examine causes and longer-term options before making major irreversible changes.
Example: A program is not producing the intended results
An evaluation shows that a community program has not improved the outcomes it was designed to address.
The organization should not immediately assume that the program itself must be abandoned or that staff simply implemented it poorly.
Review the program design, implementation, participant access, staffing, resources, measurement, community context, and available evidence. Then decide whether to improve implementation, modify the program, test another approach, or discontinue it.
If an event is irreversible, the task becomes adaptation rather than reversal.
Identify what can still be protected, learned, repaired, or pursued through another route.
Adversity
Chronic adversity requires sustained attention, but sustained attention should not become endless continuation of the same strategy.
Establish review points.
Ask periodically:
- Is the situation improving, worsening, or remaining stable?
- Is our strategy producing results?
- Are the costs still sustainable?
- What new information has emerged?
- What assumptions have changed?
- Should we continue, adapt, reduce, pause, transfer, or stop this work?
Persistence is useful only when the direction remains responsible and worthwhile.
How do you, as a leader, respond to setbacks and adversity?
Formal leaders have particular responsibilities in difficult conditions, but they should not carry the response alone.
Boards, supervisors, staff, volunteers, community partners, professional advisers, and other participants may each hold information, expertise, authority, and responsibilities the organization needs.
Regulate your behavior without pretending to have certainty
Leaders should remain deliberate enough to think, communicate, and make decisions responsibly.
That does not mean pretending to be calm, confident, or certain when important questions remain unanswered.
You can say:
We do not yet know the full impact. Here's what we know now, what we're doing next, and when we expect to provide another update.
Acknowledging uncertainty can be more trustworthy than projecting confidence you do not actually have.
Communicate early and at regular intervals
People need accurate information during disruption.
Communicate:
- What happened
- What is known
- What remains unknown
- What the organization is doing
- What people should do now
- Where questions should go
- When the next update will come
Protect confidential information and do not speculate beyond available evidence.
If inaccurate information is circulating, correct it clearly and provide a reliable source for updates.
Establish roles and decision authority
Difficult situations become harder when nobody knows who is responsible for what.
Clarify:
- Who is coordinating the response
- Who has authority for urgent decisions
- Who communicates internally and externally
- Who manages finances
- Who handles safety, technology, legal, or other specialized issues
- Who provides updates to the Board or governing body
Roles may change as the situation moves from immediate response into recovery and longer-term adaptation.
Take action that serves a clear purpose
Action is important when it protects safety, maintains essential functions, reduces harm, gathers necessary information, or moves the response forward.
Do not take visible action merely to create the impression that leadership is in control.
Sometimes the most responsible immediate action is:
- Pausing an activity
- Securing information
- Requesting expert review
- Contacting affected people
- Preserving cash
- Activating a continuity plan
Assess what happened
Avoid jumping immediately from a problem to a person to blame.
Examine:
- What happened?
- When did it begin?
- What decisions preceded it?
- What information was available at the time?
- What assumptions were made?
- What external conditions contributed?
- What organizational systems or controls contributed?
- What worked as intended?
- What failed?
Individual accountability may still be necessary, but accountability and system analysis are not opposites.
Assess the impact
Determine how the situation affects:
- Participants and community members
- Staff and volunteers
- Safety
- Services
- Finances
- Legal or contractual obligations
- Technology and data
- Partners and funders
- Public trust
Pay particular attention to people who may experience the greatest consequences or have the fewest alternatives.
Develop a response, recovery, or adaptation plan
The plan should fit the nature of the situation.
Depending on the problem, it may include:
- Immediate stabilization
- Continuity of essential functions
- Corrective action
- Financial changes
- Staffing changes
- Program changes
- Communication
- Technology or security changes
- Partner coordination
- Recovery milestones
- Longer-term risk reduction
Identify responsibilities, resources, timelines, decision authority, and review points.
Maintain continuity of essential work
Identify the functions that must continue even when normal operations are disrupted.
Consider:
- Essential staff roles
- Backup personnel
- Remote-work or alternate-site arrangements
- Access to records and technology
- Vendor dependencies
- Communication systems
- Accessibility and accommodations
- Restoration priorities
Continuity planning should happen before a disruption whenever possible.
Involve relevant people in planning
A difficult situation may affect different parts of an organization in different ways.
Include the people whose:
- Knowledge is needed
- Responsibilities are affected
- Work will be required for implementation
- Services or communities will experience the consequences
Participation should match the decision.
An emergency safety decision may require rapid action by a clearly responsible person. Longer-term recovery and redesign may benefit from broader staff, participant, community, partner, or Board involvement.
Do not invite people into a process if the important decisions have already been made and their input cannot influence the result.
Ask for outside expertise when needed
No organization has every kind of expertise internally.
Depending on the situation, outside assistance might come from:
- Community partners
- Accountants or financial advisers
- Attorneys
- Emergency managers
- Cybersecurity professionals
- Public-health professionals
- Insurance providers
- Human-resources specialists
- Mediators
- Peer organizations that have handled similar situations
Seek expertise because it improves the response, not simply because outside involvement may improve the organization's reputation.
Protect financial sustainability
Financial adversity requires more than informal thrift or personal sacrifice from leaders and staff.
Leaders and governing bodies may need to examine:
- Current cash position
- Cash-flow projections
- Restricted and unrestricted funds
- Operating reserves
- Debt and contractual obligations
- Staffing costs
- Program commitments
- Revenue concentration
- Fundraising and grant expectations
- Scenarios for reduced or increased revenue
Cost reductions can create their own risks.
Before reducing staff, benefits, services, technology, or facilities, consider what the change will do to safety, service quality, compliance, workload, and the organization's long-term capacity.
Compensation and employment decisions should use appropriate governance and legal processes rather than relying on employees or executives to demonstrate commitment through unpaid work.
Support staff and volunteer well-being
Difficult conditions may affect people differently.
Support may include:
- Clear and regular communication
- Reasonable workload adjustments
- Rest and leave
- Backup coverage
- Flexible scheduling where appropriate
- Good supervision
- Peer support
- Access to employee assistance or other professional resources where available
Don't require people to discuss personal emotional reactions in a group in order to demonstrate teamwork.
Leaders need support as well, but they should not make employees, volunteers, participants, or people with less organizational power responsible for carrying the leader's emotional burden.
Create psychological safety
During adversity, people need to be able to communicate information leaders may not want to hear.
Create conditions in which people can:
- Report mistakes
- Raise risks
- Ask for help
- Challenge assumptions
- Admit uncertainty
- Say when workload or conditions are unsafe
Psychological safety does not eliminate accountability. It helps organizations obtain accurate information before problems become worse.
Use strengths without minimizing problems
During difficult periods, it can be useful to identify what is still working.
Ask:
- Which services remain strong?
- Which partnerships are working?
- What skills and resources can we build on?
- What did we handle better than expected?
This strengths-based approach should not become forced optimism.
People also need leaders to acknowledge losses, uncertainty, mistakes, and legitimate concerns.
Keep mission and responsibilities in view
Mission can help an organization prioritize during disruption.
Ask:
- Which work is most essential to the mission?
- Which obligations must continue?
- Which activities can be delayed or reduced?
- Does the current strategy still fit the community and the conditions?
Do not preserve a particular program or method simply because it has existed for a long time.
The mission may remain important even when the strategy used to pursue it needs substantial change.
Use social connection thoughtfully
Optional opportunities for people to connect can support relationships during difficult periods.
This may include informal check-ins, team gatherings, peer groups, or other activities appropriate to the organization.
Participation should be voluntary and accessible.
Social activities are not substitutes for adequate staffing, compensation, supervision, workload management, or professional support.
Use humor carefully
Humor may relieve tension for some people and teams.
Use judgment.
Humor should not minimize:
- Loss
- Trauma
- Layoffs
- Safety concerns
- Discrimination
- Serious financial consequences
Don't pressure people to be cheerful during genuinely difficult circumstances.
Document important decisions and actions
During fast-moving situations, decisions can be difficult to reconstruct later.
Record appropriate information such as:
- What happened
- What information was available
- Major decisions
- Who had decision authority
- Actions taken
- Known risks and uncertainties
- Follow-up responsibilities
Follow applicable confidentiality and record-retention requirements.
Review what happened
After the immediate situation stabilizes, conduct an appropriate review.
Ask:
- What happened?
- What worked?
- What did not work?
- What information arrived too late?
- Were roles and authority clear?
- Were people able to raise concerns?
- Did continuity plans work?
- What unintended consequences occurred?
- What should change before the next disruption?
Review near misses as well as major failures. A problem that almost caused serious harm can reveal vulnerabilities before a worse event occurs.
Turn lessons into organizational changes
Learning matters only if it changes practice.
Depending on what happened, update:
- Policies
- Training
- Financial controls
- Continuity plans
- Staffing or backup arrangements
- Communication systems
- Technology
- Vendor arrangements
- Program design
- Governance or escalation procedures
Make important lessons accessible so the organization does not lose them when staff or leaders change.
Know when recovery does not mean returning to the old normal
Some conditions are temporary.
Others permanently change the environment in which the organization works.
Leaders may need to decide whether to:
- Restore the previous approach
- Adapt it
- Reduce the scope of work
- Transfer a program to another organization
- Merge or share operations
- End a program
- Develop an entirely different strategy
Continuing the same activity indefinitely is not always evidence of commitment.
Sometimes resilience means changing direction.
Transition out of crisis mode
Emergency practices should not automatically become permanent.
Determine when:
- Temporary authority returns to normal governance
- Emergency staffing or schedules end
- Deferred leave can be restored
- Deferred work should resume or be discontinued
- Temporary communication procedures can end
Recovery includes restoring the people and systems that carried the organization through the difficult period.
In Summary
Setbacks and adversity are different but overlapping forms of disruption. A setback is usually a discrete event or series of events, while adversity is a difficult condition that persists or repeatedly interferes with the work.
Both require leadership, but leadership in difficult conditions does not mean projecting certainty, forcing optimism, or personally carrying the entire organization through the problem.
Effective response begins with protecting people and essential functions, understanding what is known and unknown, clarifying roles and decision authority, communicating honestly, and taking action proportionate to the situation.
Organizations should examine both immediate causes and broader system conditions, involve relevant people in planning, seek outside expertise when needed, protect financial sustainability, and support the well-being and capacity of staff and volunteers.
Persistent adverse conditions require review as well as perseverance. Organizations should be willing to modify programs, reduce scope, change strategies, or stop work that is no longer sustainable or effective.
Finally, resilience is an organizational capacity, not a heroic personal trait. It depends on preparedness, governance, financial stewardship, continuity planning, trustworthy communication, healthy working conditions, strong partnerships, learning, and the ability to adapt when circumstances change.