Community Tool Box Community Tool Box

Chapter 18. Deciding Where to Start | Community Tool Box

Chapter 18. Deciding Where to Start
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:37
Section 1. Designing Community Interventions
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:38
Main Section
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:39

Adapted from "Conducting intervention research: The design and development process" by Stephen B. Fawcett et al.

You've brought together people who want to improve conditions in the community. Perhaps the goal is to increase opportunities for physical activity, improve students' success in school, reduce exposure to violence, strengthen access to services, or address another community priority.

The desired outcome may be relatively clear. The more difficult question is what combination of actions is likely to produce that outcome.

That is the purpose of intervention development.

What is an intervention?

An intervention is a deliberate action or set of actions designed to create positive change.

Interventions can take many forms, including:

  • Programs
  • Policies
  • Organizational practices
  • Changes in services
  • Environmental or infrastructure changes
  • Communication or education efforts
  • Community initiatives
  • Partnerships or coordinated systems changes

What makes something an intervention is not its form, but its purpose: to influence conditions, practices, behaviors, systems, or environments in ways expected to improve outcomes for individuals, organizations, or communities.

Effective interventions often go beyond asking individuals to change their behavior.

They may also address:

  • Access to resources or services
  • Organizational procedures
  • Policies
  • Physical environments
  • Economic conditions
  • Information and communication systems
  • Social relationships
  • Institutional or structural barriers

An example

A community that wants to prevent sexual violence might consider several intervention approaches.

Depending on the local problem analysis and available evidence, these could include:

  • Education and skill-building that support healthy relationships, consent, bystander action, and violence prevention
  • Organizational policies and reporting systems that strengthen accountability and response
  • Accessible services and support for survivors
  • Changes to transportation, lighting, or other environmental conditions where those conditions are shown to affect safety
  • Work with schools, workplaces, community organizations, and other institutions on practices that promote safety and respect

The appropriate combination depends on the problem, evidence, community context, authority, available resources, and the mechanisms the intervention is intended to influence.

More components do not automatically make an intervention more effective.

The intervention should be complex enough to address the important contributing conditions without adding activities that do not serve a clear purpose.

Why should you develop interventions?

Intervention development provides a structured way to move from understanding a problem to taking action.

A deliberate process can help an organization:

  • Connect proposed activities to the problem they are intended to address
  • Use available research and practice evidence
  • Incorporate community knowledge and priorities
  • Make assumptions about how change is expected to occur more explicit
  • Compare alternative approaches
  • Identify implementation requirements before launch
  • Plan evaluation and monitoring
  • Learn and adapt as evidence changes

A well-designed intervention is not guaranteed to succeed.

Implementation conditions may change, evidence may be incomplete, participation may differ from what was expected, or the intervention may produce effects that were not anticipated.

Intervention design should therefore include a plan for learning as well as a plan for action.

When should you develop or redesign an intervention?

It may make sense to develop, adopt, adapt, or redesign an intervention when:

  • A clearly identified community or organizational condition warrants action
  • Existing approaches are not producing sufficient results
  • Evidence suggests that another approach could improve outcomes
  • Community priorities or conditions have changed
  • Policy, technology, funding, or other contextual changes create a new opportunity
  • An existing intervention needs to be adapted for a different setting or population

Decide whether your organization should lead the intervention

An organization may be capable of doing something without being the most appropriate organization to lead it.

Ask:

  • Does the issue fit our mission and responsibilities?
  • Do we have relevant authority?
  • Do we have or can we obtain the necessary expertise and resources?
  • Is another organization already responsible for this work?
  • Would partnership be more effective than acting alone?
  • What other priorities would receive fewer resources if we take this on?
  • Are there legal, ethical, or safety responsibilities that require us to act?

The answer may be to lead an intervention, partner with another organization, support someone else's effort, refer the issue to an appropriate authority, or address only the portion that falls within your organization's role.

How do you develop an intervention?

Intervention development is often iterative rather than strictly linear.

New evidence may change how the problem is understood. Community engagement may reveal a barrier that was previously overlooked. Pilot testing may show that a proposed activity is impractical. Evaluation may show that the intervention's assumptions need to be revised.

The steps below provide a useful structure while allowing the process to change when the evidence requires it.

1. Clarify the desired change

Begin with the condition or outcome the intervention is intended to improve.

Ask:

  • What is happening now?
  • What outcome do we want to improve?
  • Who or what is affected?
  • What evidence shows that the issue warrants attention?
  • What would meaningful improvement look like?

Do not begin by assuming that individual behavior must be the primary target.

Depending on the problem, meaningful change may require changes in:

  • Individual knowledge or behavior
  • Relationships and social support
  • Organizational practice
  • Services
  • Access
  • Physical environments
  • Funding or resource allocation
  • Policies or regulations
  • Larger systems

2. Establish a baseline and understand the scope of the issue

Gather enough information to understand the current condition and to provide a baseline against which later change can be assessed.

Depending on the question, sources may include:

  • Administrative or program records
  • Public datasets
  • Surveys
  • Interviews
  • Focus groups or community listening activities
  • Direct observation
  • Research evidence
  • Geographic information
  • Policy and organizational documents
  • Community and lived experience

Ask:

  • How large is the issue?
  • How severe is it?
  • Where does it occur?
  • How has it changed over time?
  • Are some groups or locations affected differently?
  • What information is missing?

Examine the quality and limitations of the evidence rather than assuming that every available measure describes the problem equally well.

3. Identify who is affected and who needs to be involved

An intervention may affect more people and organizations than the people who directly experience the desired outcome.

Identify:

  • People and communities directly affected
  • People who use or receive the intervention
  • Staff or volunteers who would implement it
  • Organizations whose practices may need to change
  • Decision-makers with relevant authority
  • Partners who control needed resources or infrastructure
  • People who may experience unintended costs or burdens

Avoid defining people as "targets" simply because the intervention is intended to influence a behavior or decision.

Be specific about what the intervention is trying to influence and why.

4. Engage people and communities meaningfully

People affected by an intervention may have knowledge about barriers, resources, implementation conditions, history, and priorities that planners do not have.

Engagement should begin early enough to influence important decisions rather than being used only to obtain approval for a plan that has already been developed.

Clarify:

  • What participants can influence
  • What has already been decided
  • Who has final decision authority
  • How participant input will be used
  • How the organization will report back on what happened

Meaningful participation does not automatically create "ownership" or guarantee support for an intervention.

Participants may contribute substantially and still disagree with the final decision.

Make engagement accessible

Depending on the context, consider:

  • Language access
  • Disability access
  • Transportation
  • Childcare or caregiving demands
  • Meeting schedules
  • Technology
  • Remote participation
  • Compensation for substantial community time or expertise where appropriate
  • Anonymous or confidential input where power differences create risk

5. Analyze contributing conditions

Examine why the issue exists and what conditions maintain or reduce it.

Do not assume that one underlying cause explains a complex community problem.

Ask:

  • What conditions contribute to the problem?
  • What conditions protect against it?
  • What policies or institutional practices matter?
  • What environmental or infrastructure conditions matter?
  • What individual or interpersonal factors matter?
  • What economic or resource conditions matter?
  • How do these factors interact?
  • Which explanations are well supported?
  • Which explanations remain hypotheses?

Example

Suppose a community is trying to reduce housing instability.

The analysis might examine:

  • Rental prices and housing supply
  • Income and employment stability
  • Eviction practices
  • Availability of emergency assistance
  • Disability and health-related needs
  • Domestic violence
  • Discrimination
  • Reentry from institutions
  • Access to legal assistance
  • Local and state housing policy

An intervention based only on employment training would miss many of these pathways.

6. Define goals and objectives

Describe what the intervention should accomplish before deciding exactly which activities will be used.

Goals describe the broader desired outcome.

Objectives describe specific changes the intervention intends to produce.

Strong objectives identify:

  • What will change
  • For whom or what
  • By how much, where appropriate
  • By when
  • How the change will be measured

Objectives should reflect outcomes the intervention can reasonably influence.

Avoid writing objectives that place responsibility for complex outcomes entirely on individuals when important system or environmental barriers remain.

7. Describe how change is expected to occur

Before choosing activities, make the intervention's logic explicit.

A logic model, theory of change, program roadmap, or similar tool can connect:

  • The identified problem and context
  • Contributing conditions
  • Resources or inputs
  • Intervention activities
  • Immediate outputs
  • Short-term outcomes
  • Intermediate outcomes
  • Longer-term outcomes
  • Important assumptions

Ask:

If we carry out these activities, why do we expect these outcomes to change?

The answer should be supported by a reasonable combination of evidence, theory, local knowledge, and clearly identified assumptions.

8. Learn from existing evidence and practice

Before creating a completely new intervention, examine what has already been tried.

Sources may include:

  • Systematic reviews
  • Evidence-based recommendations and guidelines
  • Peer-reviewed research
  • Government and professional guidance
  • Evaluations of similar programs
  • Local and regional initiatives
  • Community experience

Consider both successful and unsuccessful efforts.

An intervention that worked elsewhere may not produce the same results in a different setting.

9. Assess whether an existing intervention fits the context

When considering an established approach, ask:

  • Does it address the contributing conditions identified here?
  • What evidence supports its effectiveness?
  • In which populations and settings has it been studied?
  • How similar are those conditions to ours?
  • What resources and expertise does implementation require?
  • Is it accessible to the people intended to benefit?
  • What effects has it had on equity?
  • What unintended consequences have been reported?
  • Can our organization implement it with adequate quality?
  • Does it fit our legitimate mission and authority?

10. Decide whether to adopt, adapt, combine, or develop

The group may decide to:

  • Adopt an established intervention largely as designed
  • Adapt an established intervention to fit the local context
  • Combine compatible strategies
  • Improve an existing local approach
  • Develop a new intervention when available approaches do not adequately address the problem

Adapt thoughtfully

When modifying an intervention with existing evidence, distinguish between:

  • Essential functions or mechanisms believed to produce the outcome
  • Delivery details that can reasonably be changed to improve local fit

An adaptation that removes the mechanism responsible for effectiveness may no longer be the same intervention.

Document significant adaptations so their effects can be interpreted during evaluation.

11. Generate additional intervention options

Existing evidence may not provide a complete answer.

Generate additional options when necessary.

Useful approaches include:

  • Individual idea generation
  • Brainwriting
  • Structured brainstorming
  • Community design sessions
  • Process mapping
  • Systems mapping

Generate broadly while respecting legal, ethical, safety, rights, and scope boundaries.

12. Compare intervention options

Compare potential interventions using explicit criteria.

These may include:

  • Relevance: Does the intervention address the problem and contributing conditions?
  • Evidence: What is known about effectiveness?
  • Equity: Who is likely to benefit, and who may experience additional barriers or burdens?
  • Accessibility: Can the intended participants actually use or benefit from it?
  • Feasibility: Can it be implemented with available or obtainable staff, authority, time, technology, partnerships, and other resources?
  • Safety: What harms or risks might occur?
  • Ethics and legality: Is it consistent with rights, professional responsibilities, law, and organizational policy?
  • Cost: What resources are required?
  • Opportunity cost: What other work may receive fewer resources?
  • Acceptability: How do relevant participants and communities understand the intervention and its effects?
  • Sustainability: What would be required to maintain it if it proves useful?
  • Reversibility: Can it be modified or stopped if assumptions prove wrong?
  • Evaluation: Can meaningful implementation and outcome measures be collected?

Several intervention options may remain reasonable after evaluation.

Document important tradeoffs and the reasons for selecting the approach.

13. Understand implementation facilitators, barriers, and concerns

Before launch, examine what may help or interfere with implementation.

Possible factors include:

  • Staffing
  • Training
  • Funding
  • Leadership support
  • Community trust
  • Technology
  • Facilities
  • Transportation
  • Language and disability access
  • Policy or legal requirements
  • Partner capacity
  • Competing priorities

If people or organizations oppose the proposed intervention, determine why.

Opposition may reveal:

  • Legitimate risks
  • Conflicting priorities
  • Rights or legal concerns
  • Accessibility problems
  • Unanticipated costs or burdens
  • Inadequate communication or engagement
  • Misinformation

Respond to the substance of the concern rather than treating all resistance as an obstacle to overcome.

14. Identify intervention components and activities

Break the intervention into the major components necessary to carry out its theory of change.

Possible intervention strategies include:

  • Providing information or skill-building
  • Strengthening services and supports
  • Removing access barriers
  • Changing organizational procedures
  • Changing policies or regulations
  • Modifying physical environments
  • Improving infrastructure
  • Changing resource allocation
  • Improving coordination among organizations
  • Using communication or outreach strategies
  • Monitoring implementation and providing feedback

Not every intervention needs every type of strategy.

Select components because they address identified contributing conditions and support the expected pathway to change.

15. Specify the intervention clearly

For each major component, describe:

  • What activity will occur
  • Who or what it is intended to influence
  • Who will deliver or implement it
  • Where and when it will occur
  • What resources are required
  • What level or amount of activity is expected
  • What implementation quality is required
  • How accessibility will be addressed
  • How the component connects to the intended outcome

Specific intervention descriptions make implementation, replication, adaptation, and evaluation easier.

16. Develop an action plan

Translate the intervention design into specific implementation responsibilities.

The action plan should identify:

  • Components and activities
  • Responsible owners
  • Required approvals and decision authority
  • Supporting partners
  • Timelines and milestones
  • Dependencies
  • Resources
  • Accessibility requirements
  • Communication responsibilities
  • Major risks and contingency plans
  • Monitoring and evaluation responsibilities

17. Plan evaluation before implementation

Do not wait until the intervention is finished to decide how success will be assessed.

Identify:

  • The purpose of the evaluation
  • Who will use the findings
  • The questions the evaluation needs to answer
  • Indicators and measures
  • Baseline information
  • Data sources
  • How and when data will be collected
  • Who is responsible for collection and analysis
  • Privacy, confidentiality, and ethical requirements

Distinguish types of evaluation

Different questions require different approaches.

  • Formative evaluation can examine whether the intervention is feasible, appropriate, understandable, accessible, and ready for implementation.
  • Process or implementation evaluation examines how the intervention was delivered, who was reached, how much was delivered, what adaptations occurred, and what helped or hindered implementation.
  • Outcome evaluation examines whether the intended outcomes changed.
  • Impact evaluation uses designs intended to determine whether the intervention caused observed changes.
  • Economic evaluation can examine costs in relation to results.

Match evaluation rigor to the questions, stakes, available resources, intervention maturity, and claims the organization hopes to make.

18. Pilot or test when appropriate

A pilot can help determine whether an intervention or implementation process works as expected on a smaller scale.

Pilot testing can be useful when:

  • The intervention is new
  • Important implementation assumptions remain uncertain
  • The organization is adapting an approach substantially
  • Accessibility or usability needs testing
  • A limited test can reduce the risks of a larger rollout

A pilot may not be appropriate when urgent protective action is required or when delaying a well-supported intervention would create unnecessary harm.

Before the pilot, decide:

  • What is being tested
  • Who will participate
  • How long the test will run
  • What data will be collected
  • What unintended effects will be monitored
  • What findings would support expansion
  • What findings would require modification, another test, or stopping

Use participant and implementer feedback alongside other evidence.

19. Implement the intervention

Implementation is a major phase of the work, not simply the execution of a finished design.

During implementation, monitor:

  • Whether activities are occurring
  • Whether they are being delivered with appropriate quality
  • Whether the intended participants are being reached
  • Whether staffing and resources are sufficient
  • Whether important barriers have emerged
  • Whether adaptations are occurring
  • Whether unintended consequences are appearing

20. Adapt deliberately when necessary

Real-world implementation often requires adjustment.

Adaptation may be appropriate when:

  • Community conditions change
  • The intervention is not accessible as designed
  • Implementation barriers emerge
  • New evidence becomes available
  • A component is not functioning as expected

Document important adaptations.

Record:

  • What changed
  • Why it changed
  • Who approved the change
  • Whether the theory of change was affected
  • How the change affects evaluation

21. Evaluate outcomes and unintended effects

Evaluation should answer more than whether the intervention was completed.

Ask:

  • Was the intervention implemented as intended?
  • Who was reached?
  • Who was not reached?
  • Did the intended outcomes improve?
  • For whom did they improve?
  • Under what conditions?
  • Were important disparities reduced, maintained, or increased?
  • What unintended positive or negative effects occurred?
  • What did implementation cost?

Outcome change by itself does not necessarily establish that the intervention caused the change.

The strength of the causal conclusion depends on the evaluation design and available evidence.

22. Use the findings

Evaluation should inform action.

Based on implementation experience and findings, decide whether to:

  • Continue the intervention
  • Improve particular components
  • Adapt delivery
  • Expand or scale the intervention
  • Reduce its scope
  • Test an alternative
  • Stop the intervention

Avoid continuing an ineffective or harmful intervention simply because substantial resources have already been invested in it.

23. Communicate what happened

Report findings to the people and organizations who need them.

If community members or participants helped shape the intervention, close the feedback loop.

Explain:

  • What was implemented
  • What was learned
  • What outcomes occurred
  • What limitations remain
  • What was changed because of participant or community input
  • What will happen next

24. Continue monitoring and learning

An intervention that works today may need to change as community conditions, resources, policies, technology, or participant needs change.

Continue to monitor:

  • Implementation quality
  • Reach
  • Outcomes
  • Equity
  • Cost
  • Sustainability
  • Context
  • Unintended effects

Use those findings to refine the intervention and its underlying assumptions.

In Summary

Developing an intervention means moving systematically from an identified problem or desired outcome to a practical, evidence-informed approach for creating change.

Begin by understanding the problem, its context, the people and communities affected, and the conditions that contribute to it. Do not assume in advance that individual behavior is the main cause or that behavior change is the only appropriate intervention.

Engage people affected by the intervention early enough for their knowledge and priorities to influence important decisions, while being transparent about decision authority and how input will be used.

Define clear goals and objectives, describe how the proposed activities are expected to lead to outcomes, and examine existing evidence before deciding whether to adopt, adapt, combine, improve, or create an intervention.

Select intervention components because they address identified contributing conditions and fit the evidence, context, authority, resources, accessibility needs, equity considerations, and implementation capacity.

Plan implementation and evaluation together. Establish responsibilities, timelines, resources, indicators, data sources, and criteria for adapting, expanding, or stopping the intervention before implementation begins.

Finally, treat intervention development as a learning process. Monitor how the intervention is actually implemented, evaluate intended and unintended effects, communicate results, and be willing to revise both the intervention and the assumptions behind it when the evidence changes.

Contributor

Jenette Nagy

Stephen B. Fawcett

Resources

Online Resources

Community Health Advisor from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation is a helpful online tool with detailed information about evidence-based polices and programs to reduce tobacco use and increase physical activity in communities.

The Society for Community Research and Action serves many different disciplines that are involved in strategies to improve communities. It hosts a general electronic discussion list as well as several by special interest.

The U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development features "Success Stories" and gives ideas for ways to solve problems in your community.

The National Civic League provides a database of Success Stories.

The Pew Partnership for Civic Change offers several resources for promising solutions for building strong communities.

The World Health Organization provides information on many types of interventions around the world.

Print Resources

Fawcett, S., Suarez, Y. Balcazar, F., White, G., Paine, A., Blanchard, K., & Embree, M. (1994). Conducting intervention research: The design and development process. In J. Rothman & E. J. Thomas (Eds.), Intervention research: Design and development for human service. (pp. 25-54). New York, NY: Haworth Press.

Checklist
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:40

___You understand that an intervention can be a program, a change in policy, or a practice that becomes popular

___You understand that interventions focus on people's behaviors, and how changes in the environment can support those behaviors

___You understand the advantages of developing interventions

___You understand when you should develop or redesign interventions

Developing the intervention:

___You have decided what needs to happen

___You have used a measurement system to gather information about the level of the problem

___You have decided whom the intervention needs to help

___You have involved potential clients or end users of the intervention

___With these clients, you have identified the issues or problems you will attempt to solve together

___You have analyzed these problems or the issue to be addressed in the intervention

___You have set goals and objectives

___You have learned what others have done

___You have brainstormed your own ideas

___You have tried to decide what interventions or parts of interventions have worked, and what might be applicable to your situation

___You have identified barriers and resistance you might come up against

___You have identified core components and elements of the intervention

___You have developed an action plan to carry out the intervention

___You have pilot-tested your intervention

___You have implemented your intervention

Examples
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:40

Example 1: "Caring Pairs" Components and Elements Background Table

Problem/Issue to be Addressed Pairing local children with adults in mutually helpful volunteer opportunities
Risk/Protective Factors Opportunities to serve
Stronger adult-youth relationships
Stronger peer relationships
Supervised alternative activities
Stronger community support
Social skills
Improved academic performance
Increased life options
Targets of Change Corporations, faith institutions, schools, service organizations, adults,
program staff, students, teachers, Federal and State agencies
Agents of Change Advisory Board, School District Coordinators, program staff,
current volunteers, school districts, YMCA, School District Coordinators,
Students in kindergarten through twelfth grade
Components Recruitment, matching, activities
Elements Marketing, selection, background checks, activity assignment, orientation, training
One-to-One
Mentor
Tutor
Phone pal
Career exploration
Group
After-school Facilitator
Lunch reading group
Church-school program
Saturday activities
Pregnant teen Support Group
Basketball clinic
Career Discovery Day
Mode/Context of Delivery Media, businesses, faith institutions, nonprofit organizations,
service organizations, government, schools, School District Coordinators,
field trip locations

 Example 2: "Caring Pairs" Table of Components and Elements

  Providing Information and Enhancing Skills Enhancing Support and resources Modifying opportunities and barriers Monitoring and Feedback
Components - Recruitment
- Matching
- Celebrations
- Resource Sharing
- Recognition
- Provide opportunities to serve
- Making it easier to volunteer
- Tracking the number of youth and volunteers
Elements - Promote awareness
- Selection of volunteers
- Background checks
- Activity assignment
- Orientation
- Training
- Monthly celebrations
- Agency newsletter
- Articles on volunteers in town newspaper
- Change policies to allow flex time at work
Opportunities:
- Mentor
- Tutor
- Phone Pal
- Career Exploration
- After-school Facilitator
- Lunch Reading Group
- Church-School Program
- Saturday activities
- Pregnant teen Support Group
- Basketball clinic
- Career Discovery Day
- How many hours are spent by volunteers and youth?
- How many volunteers and youth are involved?

 Example 3: Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program Components and Elements Background Table

Problem/Issue to be Addressed Adolescent pregnancy is a serious problem in our community
Risk/Protective Factors Knowledge of contraceptives, risks
Access to contraceptives
Skills
Values and beliefs
Problems at home (conflict, inconsistent rules from parents)
Economic deprivation
Targets of Change Adolescents, peers, parents and caregivers, teachers, service providers, business people, and elected and appointed officials
Agents of Change Peers, parents and caregivers, teachers, service providers, religious leaders, business people, elected and appointed officials
Components Sexuality education, develop community alliances, improve access to contraceptives, monitor rates of adolescent pregnancy, improve peer support, increase alternative activities
Elements Offer graduate-level training for teachers in sexuality education
Offer skills training for teens for the choice of avoiding unprotected sexual activity
Use bulletin boards and the school newspaper to keep teens up-to-date on special events
Begin a "brown bag" program for teens to buy contraceptives without others knowing what they are doing
Start a support group to help teen mothers stay in school
Mode/Context of Delivery Schools, media, businesses, faith institutions, service organizations

 Example 4: Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program Table of Components and Elements

  Providing Information and skills training Enhancing support and resources Modifying opportunities and barriers Monitoring and Feedback
Components - Sexuality education - Provide peer support
- Provide support from influential others
- Develop community alliances
- Improve access to contraceptives - Monitor rates of adolescent pregnancy
Elements - Offer graduate-level training for teachers in sexuality education
- Offer skills training to teens on avoiding unprotected sexual activity
- Use bulletin boards and the school newspaper to keep teens up-to-date on special events
- Start a support group to help teen mothers stay in school
- Establish a mentoring program for at-risk youth to gain access to potential employers and job opportunities
- Begin a "brown bag" program for teens to buy contraceptives without others knowing what they are doing
- Contraception and information about its use will be made available at places where teens congregate
- How many teens report abstaining from intercourse?
- How many teens report the use of contraceptives if they do engage in sexual activity?
- How many teens become pregnant?
- Report the estimated pregnancy rate to the community on an annual basis

 Example 5: Neighborhood Revitalization Project Components and Elements Background Table

Problem/Issue to be Addressed We want to improve neighborhood life through better jobs, housing, and education.
Risk/Protective Factors Economic deprivation
Community disorganization
Mobility
Availability of illegal substances / weapons
Skills training
Targets of Change Business people, residents (including youth), elected and appointed officials, funders, higher education institutions
Agents of Change Business people, residents (including youth), elected and appointed officials, funders, higher education institutions
Components Job training, job availability, land reorganization, monitoring of joblessness, education and training
Elements Develop adult literacy programs
Expand affordable childcare
Expand computer access for residents through local community organization
Hold an annual job fair
Provide loans to support small business development
Clear land for new business
Increase incentives to encourage rehabilitation of existing housing
Increase clean up of yards, sidewalks, and vacant lots
Build more low- and middle-income housing in the neighborhood
Mode/Context of Delivery Businesses, housing authority, schools, media, faith institutions, service organizations

Example 6: Neighborhood Revitalization Project Table of Components and Elements

  Providing information and skils training Enhancing support and resources Modifying opportunities and barriers Monitoring and Feedback
Components - Increase job training
- Provide information on job training
- Increase general education
- Provide support for new businesses
- Provide financial support for home rehabilitation
- Reduce barriers to going to work
- Reorganize land use
- Monitoring joblessness, education
Elements - Develop adult literacy programs
- Hold an annual job fair
- Develop programs to help residents obtain their GED
- Increase the number of computers in schools
- Establish a summer internship program for high school students
- Provide low interest loans to encourage rehabilitation of existing housing
- Build more low- and middle-income h ousing in the neighborhood
- Institute tax breaks for employers who relocate in the neighborhood
- Expand affordable childcare
- Expand computer access for residents through local community organizations
- Provide loans to support small business development
- Clear land for new business
- Improve the public transportation system
- What is the rate of unemployment for the neighborhood?
- What percentage of high school freshmen graduate high school or obtain a GED?
- What percentage of high school students receive further education?

 

Tools
mloewenstein Thu, 01/03/2013 - 10:20

Tool 1: Problem analysis sheet

The following page gives you room to analyze the problem or issue you want your group to address. This information can then be used to help you set goals and objectives.

What factors put people at risk for (or protect them against) the problem or concern?                                                                                                                                                           
Whose behavior (or lack of behavior) caused the problem?  

Whose behavior (or lack of behavior) maintains the problem?

 
For whom is the situation a problem?

 

 

What are the negative consequences for those directly affected?  
What are the negative consequences for the community?  
Who, if anyone, benefits from things being the way they are now?  
How do they benefit?  
Who should share the responsibility for solving the problem?  
What behaviors need to change to consider the problem "solved"?  
What conditions need to change to address the issue or problem?  
How much change is necessary?  
At what level(s) should the problem be addressed?  
Will you be able to make changes at the level(s) identified?  

Tool 2: Components and Elements Background Table

Use this table to look holistically at the intervention you will develop.

  Providing Information and Skills Training Enhancing Support
Problem/Issue to be Addressed

 

 

 
Risk/Protective Factors

 

 

 
Targets of Change

 

 

 
Agents of Change

 

 

 
Components

 

 

 
Elements

 

 

 
Mode/Context of Delivery

 

 

 

 Tool 3: Table of Components and Elements

  Providing Information and Skills Training Enhancing Support and Resources Modifying Opportunities and Barriers Monitoring and Feedback
Components

 

 

 

 

     
Elements

 

 

 

 

     

Tool 4: Determining if interventions done by others are appropriate for your purpose and situation

Use this table to help you determine if a particular intervention you know about is right for your purpose and situation.

What is the intervention?

                                                                                                                                                           

 

Is it appropriate for our purpose?

 

 

Is it effective?

 

 

Is it replaceable?

 

 

Is it simple?

 

 

Is it practical?

 

 

Is it compatible with our situation?

 

 

Additional domments:

 

 

 

PowerPoint
Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:41

A PowerPoint presentation summarizing the major points in the section.

Section 2. Participatory Approaches to Planning Community Interventions
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:50
Main Section
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:50
  • What is a participatory approach to planning?

  • What are the advantages of a participatory planning approach?

  • What are the challenges of a participatory planning approach?

  • What are the levels of participatory planning?

  • When is participatory planning appropriate?

  • When might participatory planning need to be adapted?

  • Who should be involved in a participatory planning process?

  • What do you have to do to get a participatory planning process up and running?

 

 

Community interventions are often stronger when people affected by the issue have meaningful opportunities to influence how the intervention is understood, designed, implemented, and evaluated.

That does not mean that every person must participate in every decision or that every planning process should give participants the same amount of authority.

Participatory planning means deliberately involving relevant people and communities in ways that match the purpose of the process and the influence they have been promised.

Done well, participation can improve local knowledge, reveal barriers that planners might otherwise miss, strengthen relationships, identify community assets, and produce plans that better reflect the context in which they will be implemented.

Done poorly, participation can become performative. People may be asked for input after important decisions have already been made, invited to meetings without having meaningful influence, or repeatedly asked for information without receiving feedback about what happened.

The quality of participatory planning therefore depends not simply on how many people participate, but on how clearly their role is defined, how equitably the process is designed, how power and resources are handled, and whether commitments made during engagement are honored.

What is a participatory approach to planning?

A participatory approach is one in which people and organizations with relevant interests, knowledge, responsibilities, or experience have meaningful opportunities to contribute to planning.

Depending on the issue, participants may include:

  • People and communities directly affected
  • People who will use or participate in the intervention
  • Community organizations and networks
  • Staff or volunteers who will implement the intervention
  • Service providers
  • Government agencies or officials with relevant authority
  • Funders or resource partners
  • Researchers or people with relevant technical expertise
  • Other people who may experience significant benefits, burdens, or unintended effects

Participation does not require everyone to be present in the same meeting.

Engagement may occur through:

  • Community meetings
  • Advisory groups
  • Interviews
  • Focus groups
  • Surveys
  • Workshops
  • Small-group conversations
  • Shared documents
  • Digital engagement
  • Virtual meetings
  • Written or anonymous input
  • Community-led planning groups

Be clear about the degree of influence

Not every participatory process gives participants the same role in the final decision.

Before asking people to participate, explain what they can influence.

For example, an organization might:

  • Provide information about a decision or program
  • Ask for feedback
  • Involve community members throughout development
  • Collaborate with community partners in developing and selecting options
  • Place final authority for a particular decision in a community-led body

These approaches involve different levels of influence.

Do not describe a process as shared decision-making if the sponsoring organization retains all final authority.

Participation should be meaningful

Meaningful participation is more than asking people what they think.

Participants should understand:

  • The purpose of the process
  • What decisions are open to influence
  • What has already been decided
  • Who has final authority
  • What information is available
  • How their input will be documented and used
  • How the organization will report back on the result

Participants should be able to question assumptions, disagree, offer alternative ideas, and identify risks without being expected to endorse the final plan.

Recognize different forms of knowledge

Community members may bring:

  • Lived experience
  • Local history
  • Knowledge of community relationships and institutions
  • Cultural and linguistic knowledge
  • Practical knowledge about how services work in everyday life

Other participants may bring professional, organizational, legal, policy, research, financial, or technical expertise.

These forms of knowledge answer different questions.

A strong planning process uses them together rather than assuming that professional expertise automatically overrides community knowledge or that lived experience automatically settles every technical or factual question.

Recognize power differences

Participants may enter the process with very different levels of authority, resources, status, information, and freedom to disagree.

Ask:

  • Who controls funding?
  • Who has formal decision authority?
  • Who supervises or evaluates other participants?
  • Who controls important information?
  • Who may experience consequences for speaking openly?

When these differences could suppress participation, consider confidential interviews, anonymous input, separate sessions, community-led meetings, or other ways to reduce the pressure created by hierarchy.

What are the advantages of a participatory planning approach?

Participatory planning can provide important benefits when the engagement is genuine and well designed.

  • It can improve understanding of the issue. People affected by the intervention may identify barriers, strengths, history, and practical realities that are not visible in administrative data or professional planning.
  • It can broaden the range of ideas. Participants with different experiences and expertise may identify options that a smaller planning group would miss.
  • It can improve local fit. Participants can help determine whether a proposed intervention is accessible, understandable, feasible, and appropriate in the actual community context.
  • It can reveal unintended consequences. People may identify costs, burdens, risks, or exclusions that planners had not anticipated.
  • It can strengthen relationships. Consistent, trustworthy collaboration may improve communication and coordination among organizations and communities.
  • It can make decision-making more transparent. Participants can better understand the evidence, constraints, tradeoffs, and authority behind a decision.
  • It can strengthen implementation. People responsible for delivering an intervention may identify practical requirements early enough to address them.
  • It can strengthen community-led action. Where decision authority and resources are genuinely shared, communities can shape and lead work that reflects locally defined priorities.
  • It can build useful skills and relationships. Participants may gain experience with planning, data, evaluation, facilitation, policy, or collaborative decision-making.

These benefits are not automatic.

Participation does not guarantee trust, support, agreement, credibility, or intervention effectiveness.

Those outcomes depend on the quality of the process, the intervention itself, implementation, relationships, resources, and whether commitments made to participants are honored.

Participation and trust

Trust is not created simply by inviting people to meetings.

Organizations demonstrate trustworthiness by:

  • Being clear about their purpose
  • Providing accurate information
  • Following through on commitments
  • Acknowledging limits and uncertainty
  • Respecting confidentiality
  • Explaining how decisions are made
  • Reporting back on how input was used

Participation and community ownership

Avoid promising that people will feel ownership merely because they were involved in planning.

Meaningful influence may strengthen commitment, but participants may still disagree with the final plan.

Community-led work is most credible when communities actually hold meaningful authority, resources, or governance responsibility rather than simply being described as owners of a plan controlled by another organization.

What are the challenges of a participatory planning approach?

Participatory planning can require substantial time, coordination, resources, and attention.

It requires resources

Meaningful participation may require:

  • Staff time
  • Facilitation
  • Interpretation and translation
  • Accessible materials
  • Technology
  • Transportation
  • Childcare or other caregiving support
  • Meeting space
  • Compensation for substantial community time or expertise where appropriate

An organization should not design an intensive engagement process without considering the burden it places on participants.

It can take additional time

Gathering perspectives, explaining technical information, working through disagreement, and reporting back can extend a planning timeline.

That additional time may prevent later redesign or implementation problems, but organizations still need realistic schedules.

Representation is difficult

No planning group can contain every person affected by a large community intervention.

A small number of participants should not be assumed to represent everyone who shares their neighborhood, race, ethnicity, language, religion, age, disability, profession, or another characteristic.

Ask:

  • Which perspectives are represented?
  • Which are missing?
  • Who selected the representatives?
  • Are participants speaking for themselves, an organization, or a defined constituency?

Power can distort participation

A process may appear inclusive while some participants have much greater ability to shape the outcome.

Examples include:

  • Funders controlling resources
  • Employers participating with employees
  • Government officials holding final authority
  • Professionals controlling technical information
  • Organizations controlling the agenda and meeting format

Name these differences rather than pretending everyone enters the process with equal power.

Participants may disagree strongly

Disagreement is not automatically a failure.

Participants may have different:

  • Interests
  • Values
  • Evidence
  • Experiences
  • Responsibilities
  • Risk tolerance

Facilitation should help clarify these differences without forcing compromise where agreement is not necessary or appropriate.

Harmful or disruptive behavior may require intervention

Address behavior such as:

  • Persistent domination
  • Personal attacks
  • Harassment
  • Discrimination
  • Threats
  • Repeated violation of agreed process

Do not describe a participant as difficult simply because they raise an unpopular concern or strongly disagree with the sponsoring organization.

Participation can create risk

Some people may face professional, social, political, immigration-related, interpersonal, or other consequences for participating publicly or expressing particular views.

Consider whether confidential, anonymous, separate, or other forms of participation are needed.

Communities may experience participation fatigue

People may have been repeatedly surveyed, interviewed, or invited to meetings without seeing any meaningful action.

Before asking for more participation:

  • Learn what previous engagement has occurred
  • Avoid asking for information the organization already has
  • Explain what is different about the current process
  • Report back on outcomes

What are the levels of participatory planning?

Participation can involve different degrees of influence.

A useful contemporary framework distinguishes among the following approaches:

Inform

Provide balanced, timely, understandable, and accessible information about the issue, alternatives, decision, or process.

Informing people is essential communication, but by itself it does not give them influence over the decision.

Consult

Ask for feedback on a problem, analysis, proposal, alternatives, or decision.

Explain how feedback will be considered and report back on how it influenced the outcome.

Involve

Work with participants throughout the process so their concerns, knowledge, and priorities are consistently considered as alternatives are developed.

Collaborate

Partner with community participants in important parts of the decision process, such as developing alternatives, setting criteria, selecting priorities, or governing implementation.

Empower or delegate decision authority

Place final authority for a defined decision in the hands of the participating community or community-led body.

Only describe a process this way when the authority is real.

Choose the level based on the actual decision

More participation is not automatically better in every situation.

Ask:

  • What decision is being made?
  • Who has legitimate authority to make it?
  • How significantly will people be affected?
  • What knowledge is needed?
  • Are rights or legal obligations involved?
  • What level of influence can the organization genuinely promise?

Whatever level is chosen, be transparent about it from the beginning.

When is participatory planning appropriate?

Some form of engagement is useful in many community interventions, but the degree and method should fit the situation.

Information may be appropriate when:

  • A decision has already been made through a legitimate process and the remaining task is to communicate it clearly
  • The organization is reporting on work already underway
  • People need information before later participation
  • A legal, safety, or emergency requirement leaves little discretion over the action itself

Even when a decision cannot be changed, people may still have useful input about implementation, accessibility, communication, or unintended effects.

Consultation may be appropriate when:

  • An organization needs feedback about existing services
  • Several feasible options are being considered
  • Community experience is needed to test assumptions or identify barriers
  • Final authority belongs to another accountable person or body

If you consult people, report back.

Explain:

  • What you heard
  • What changed because of the input
  • What did not change
  • Why

Involvement or collaboration may be appropriate when:

  • Community knowledge is important throughout planning
  • The intervention will substantially affect community conditions
  • Implementation depends on several organizations or community partners
  • The problem and potential responses are still open to significant change
  • Shared decision-making is feasible and appropriate

Community-led decision-making may be appropriate when:

  • The decision appropriately belongs to the community or a community-led body
  • Resources and authority can genuinely be transferred or shared
  • The organization is supporting a locally defined initiative rather than directing it

Urgent situations

Immediate action may be necessary when health, safety, rights, or basic needs are at serious risk.

Urgency does not always require abandoning community engagement.

Rapid engagement may occur alongside immediate action to:

  • Identify urgent community concerns
  • Improve communication
  • Identify barriers to implementation
  • Adapt the response as conditions change

When might participatory planning need to be adapted?

Instead of asking only whether participatory planning is appropriate or inappropriate, consider how the process may need to change.

When time is severely limited

Use rapid engagement methods, identify the decisions that are genuinely open, and plan deeper engagement for later phases where appropriate.

When conflict is severe

Participants may not be ready or able to meet in one shared forum.

Alternatives may include:

  • Separate stakeholder meetings
  • Confidential interviews
  • Mediation
  • Staged dialogue
  • An independent facilitator

When specialized expertise is required

Some decisions must meet technical, legal, clinical, engineering, financial, safety, or professional standards.

Community participation can still help identify:

  • Priorities
  • Practical effects
  • Access barriers
  • Acceptability
  • Implementation concerns

Be clear about which aspects are constrained by professional or legal requirements.

When participation creates safety or confidentiality concerns

Public meetings may not be appropriate for every issue.

Use confidential or anonymous methods where necessary and protect sensitive information.

When trust is low

Low trust is not necessarily a reason to avoid engagement.

Begin by:

  • Acknowledging relevant history
  • Clarifying what the organization can and cannot promise
  • Following through on small commitments
  • Working through trusted organizations or relationships where appropriate
  • Providing regular updates

When not everyone can participate directly

Use several methods rather than assuming one large meeting can represent an entire community.

Combine approaches such as:

  • Representative advisory groups
  • Open community input
  • Surveys
  • Interviews
  • Small-group sessions
  • Digital or asynchronous engagement

Who should be involved in a participatory planning process?

Begin by identifying the people and organizations whose knowledge, interests, responsibilities, authority, or exposure to consequences are relevant to the intervention.

People and communities directly affected

These may include people who:

  • Experience the issue
  • Use the service or program
  • Are intended to benefit
  • May experience burdens or unintended effects

Do not assume that one participant represents everyone who shares a demographic characteristic or community identity.

Where representation is used, clarify how representatives were selected and whom they are authorized to speak for.

Community organizations, networks, and trusted partners

Organizations and networks may contribute:

  • Community relationships
  • Historical knowledge
  • Communication channels
  • Implementation capacity
  • Subject-specific knowledge

These may include neighborhood organizations, advocacy groups, mutual-aid organizations, cultural organizations, disability organizations, faith-based organizations, youth groups, business associations, and other groups relevant to the actual community.

Do not assume that any category of organization is automatically representative or trusted.

Implementers and service providers

Include people who may be responsible for carrying out the plan or whose work would be affected.

They can identify:

  • Operational barriers
  • Staffing needs
  • Training requirements
  • Technology or infrastructure needs
  • Risks and dependencies

Decision-makers and resource holders

Depending on the issue, this may include:

  • Organizational leaders
  • Governing Boards
  • Government agencies or officials
  • Funders
  • Institutions controlling relevant facilities, data, or resources

Include these participants because of their actual role in the issue, not simply because of status.

People with relevant professional or technical expertise

Depending on the intervention, expertise may involve:

  • Public health
  • Health care
  • Education
  • Law
  • Evaluation
  • Engineering
  • Finance
  • Accessibility
  • Technology
  • Other relevant fields

People who may be missing from ordinary planning processes

Ask whether usual recruitment methods systematically exclude people because of:

  • Work schedules
  • Transportation
  • Disability
  • Language
  • Caregiving responsibilities
  • Technology access
  • Institutional distrust
  • Fear of consequences

Address barriers where possible rather than concluding that nonparticipation means lack of interest.

What do you have to do to get a participatory planning process up and running?

Clarify the purpose before recruiting participants

Before inviting people, define:

  • The issue or decision
  • The purpose of engagement
  • Which decisions are open
  • Who holds final authority
  • What degree of participant influence is being offered
  • The expected timeline
  • How participation will affect the final plan

These points should be communicated honestly when people are recruited.

Identify relevant participants

Ask more than:

Who will be directly affected?

Also ask:

  • Who experiences indirect effects?
  • Who has relevant knowledge?
  • Who implements the work?
  • Who controls necessary resources?
  • Who has decision authority?
  • Who might experience costs or unintended consequences?
  • Whose perspective is usually missing?

Recruit through several channels

Use communication methods that fit the actual community.

These may include:

  • Direct outreach through community organizations
  • Personal invitations
  • Email
  • Text messaging
  • Websites
  • Social media
  • Community newsletters
  • Local media
  • Flyers or posters
  • Public meetings or presentations
  • Schools, libraries, service organizations, businesses, or other community locations

Do not assume that one communication channel will reach everyone.

Make invitations clear and accessible

Explain:

  • Why the person is being invited
  • What the process is about
  • What influence participants will have
  • What time commitment is expected
  • Whether compensation or reimbursement is available
  • How to request language, disability, or other participation support

Use plain language, appropriate languages, and accessible formats.

Reduce participation barriers

Consider providing:

  • Compensation where appropriate
  • Transportation assistance
  • Childcare or caregiving support
  • Interpretation
  • Accessible materials
  • Remote participation
  • Multiple meeting times
  • Technology support

Choose an appropriate convener

The person or organization convening the process sends an important signal about who controls it.

Consider:

  • Credibility with relevant participants
  • Conflicts of interest
  • Formal authority
  • Relationships with the community
  • Ability to follow through on commitments

A well-known public figure is not automatically the best convener.

Decide whether you need a facilitator

A facilitator may be especially useful when:

  • The group is large or diverse
  • Significant power differences exist
  • Conflict is expected
  • The sponsoring organization has a strong substantive position
  • The planning process is complex

An outside facilitator can provide independence, but outside status alone does not make someone neutral or effective.

Consider facilitation skill, credibility, cultural and community understanding, accessibility competence, conflicts of interest, and ability to manage the specific process.

Convene participation in ways that fit the community

A large public meeting is only one option.

Depending on the community and issue, use:

  • One large meeting
  • Several smaller meetings
  • Neighborhood or constituency-specific sessions
  • Individual interviews
  • Virtual or hybrid meetings
  • Asynchronous written input
  • Community-led sessions

Design accessible meetings

Consider:

  • Physical accessibility
  • Transportation
  • Safety
  • Language access
  • Captioning or interpretation
  • Accessible documents
  • Acoustics
  • Technology
  • Scheduling
  • Breaks
  • Remote access

Food or refreshments may be useful during longer meetings but do not substitute for accessible process design.

Use several ways for people to contribute

Participants should not have to compete for airtime in a large discussion.

Options include:

  • Spoken discussion
  • Small groups
  • Written comments
  • Chat
  • Shared documents
  • Polls
  • Anonymous questions

Allow people to decline to speak publicly.

Establish participation expectations

Clarify appropriate expectations involving:

  • Respectful disagreement
  • Confidentiality where applicable
  • Equal opportunity to contribute
  • Handling conflicts of interest
  • Harassment and discriminatory conduct
  • Recording or documentation

Clarify decision authority early

Do not wait until the end of planning to explain who can approve the plan.

Participants should understand:

  • What the planning group can decide
  • What it can recommend
  • What requires approval elsewhere
  • Which laws, policies, funding rules, or other requirements constrain the decision

Maintain the planning process

Engagement needs continuing attention after the first meeting.

Maintain:

  • Clear communication
  • Updated timelines
  • Access to relevant information
  • Participation support
  • Documentation of decisions
  • Follow-up on commitments

Provide updates even when progress is slow.

Close the feedback loop

At important decision points, tell participants:

  • What you heard
  • What decisions were made
  • How community input influenced those decisions
  • What recommendations were not adopted
  • Why
  • What happens next

Asking for participation without reporting back can damage trust and contribute to participation fatigue.

Continue engagement during implementation

Community participation should not necessarily end when the plan is approved.

Participants may help:

  • Identify implementation barriers
  • Monitor unintended effects
  • Review progress
  • Recommend adaptations
  • Evaluate outcomes

Protect information appropriately

If engagement collects personal information, recordings, contact information, demographic information, or other sensitive data, establish:

  • What information will be collected
  • Why it is needed
  • Who can access it
  • How it will be stored
  • How long it will be retained
  • How findings will be reported without creating unnecessary privacy risk

Evaluate the participation process

Ask:

  • Did the process include the people and perspectives that were needed?
  • Who was missing?
  • Were important participation barriers addressed?
  • Was the promised degree of influence actually provided?
  • Did participants understand the decision process?
  • Was participation adequately resourced?
  • Were disagreements and power differences handled appropriately?
  • Did participants receive feedback about how their input was used?

Use what you learn to improve future engagement.

Decide how long engagement will continue

A participatory process may support:

  • One planning decision
  • A specific intervention
  • Ongoing implementation oversight
  • Evaluation
  • A long-term community partnership

Be clear about when a particular group or advisory process will end, continue, or transition into another role.

In Summary

Participatory planning can strengthen community interventions by bringing relevant knowledge, experience, priorities, and implementation realities into the planning process.

Effective participation is not measured simply by how many people attend a meeting. It depends on whether people understand the purpose of the process, have appropriate opportunities to influence it, receive the information and support needed to participate, and know how their input affects decisions.

Different decisions call for different degrees of participation. An organization may inform, consult, involve, collaborate with, or delegate defined decision authority to community participants. Whatever approach is used, the promised degree of influence should be clear from the beginning.

Participatory planning also requires attention to power, representation, accessibility, compensation, confidentiality, community history, and the practical burden placed on participants.

Communities contain multiple perspectives. No individual participant, organization, demographic group, professional, or public official should automatically be treated as representing the whole community.

Trust develops through trustworthy conduct: accurate information, transparency, follow-through, respect for community knowledge and self-determination, appropriate sharing of authority and resources, and honest communication about limits.

Finally, engagement should not stop once a plan has been written. Continue appropriate collaboration through implementation and evaluation, report back on decisions and results, and adapt both the intervention and the engagement process when experience shows that changes are needed.

Contributor

Phil Rabinowitz

Resources

Online Resources

Chapter 18: Dissemination and Implementation in the "Introduction to Community Psychology" explains why “validated” and “effective” interventions are often never used, effective ways to put research findings to use in order to improve health, and advantages of participatory methods that provide more equitable engagement in the creation and use of scientific knowledge.

Increased Focus on "Participatory" Planning. Short articles on participation and its advantages.

Learning for Sustainability
Links and articles on participation and many other topics linked to community activism and development. A lot of material related to environmental issues, but plenty of general information and material on other areas as well. Check out the search engine at the top of the page, labeled "Select another area of interest." A great resource.

Mekonginfo, Regional Information System on Participatory Natural Resource Management
Effective Involvement of Ethnic Minorities in Participatory Planning (Experiences from Yunnan, China), by Dr. Hermann J. Tillmann. Analysis of a participatory planning initiative and some of the difficulties it faces.

Participatory Methods is a website that provides resources to generate ideas and action for inclusive development and social change.

Checklist
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:51

What is a participatory planning approach?

___You know that a participatory planning approach means that all stakeholders' voices are heard and respected, and that everyone has some role in decision-making.

What are the advantages of a participatory planning approach?

___Participation carries with it feelings of ownership, and builds a strong base for the intervention in the community

___It ensures that the intervention will have more credibility in all segments of the community because it was planned by a group representing all segments of the community

___It brings a broader range of people to the planning process provides access to a broader range of perspectives and ideas

___Avoids pitfalls caused by ignorance of the realities of the community or the target population

___It involves important players from the outset

___It can provide an opportunity for often-disenfranchised groups to be heard

___It teaches skills which last far beyond the planning process,and can help to improve the community over the long term

___It can bring together and establish ties among community members who might normally have no contact

___It builds trust, both between your organization and the community and among the individuals involved

___It generally reflects the mission and goals of grass roots and community-based organizations

___It implies respect for everyone in the community

___It is generally effective

___It does things the way they should be done

What are the disadvantages of a participatory planning approach?

___A participatory process takes longer

___Members of the target population or the community may not agree with the "experts " about what is needed

___Lots of education may be needed, both for community members and the organization

___One determined individual can wreck the whole process if he's not handled well

___It may be difficult to assure that all the right people get to the table

___A participatory planning process takes patience and commitment on everyone's part

What are the levels of participatory planning?

___Information

___Consultation

___Deciding together

___Acting together

___Supporting local initiatives

When is participatory planning appropriate?

___Information-only may be appropriate when:

  • The course of action has already been decided - by a funder, for instance
  • You're simply reporting on something that's already in progress
  • You're keeping people informed so that they'll have the information to be part of a participatory effort later

___Consultation-only may be appropriate when:

  • You want to evaluate or improve existing services
  • There are limited options, and you're trying to choose among them
  • There are technical reasons - again, perhaps because of a funder - why only certain people or groups can be officially involved in the planning process

___Acting together may be appropriate when:

  • The intervention will be more effective than if it were run by a single entity
  • There is a funder's requirement for community oversight
  • There is commitment to the development of a real partnership
  • Everyone benefits from acting together
  • One goal of the intervention is the eventual assumption of leadership or the learning of leadership skills by the target population and/or others in the community

___Supporting local initiatives may be appropriate when:

  • There is a commitment to community empowerment.
  • The community has the desire and at least some of the tools to start and run a successful intervention.
  • There is a commitment to provide training and support where needed.
  • Your organization can only provide support, or can only run an intervention for a short time.

When isn't participatory planning appropriate?

___When there's simply no time

___When a community is so brutally divided, it's impossible to get all - or even any - of the rival factions to the same table

___When there's no way to provide proper support - facilitation, structure, etc. - for the process

___When the target population is simply not interested in participating, and just wants the organization to take care of it

___When the intervention rests on technical knowledge of a kind that the target population and community members simply don't have

___When involving all or most stakeholders simply isn't logistically possible, because of distance, time, or other issues

___When funding constraints or funders' regulations don't allow it

___When there is no trust between your organization and the community

Who should be involved in a participatory planning process?

___Targets of change

  • Members of the target community
  • People whom the target community sees as significant opinion makers

___Agents of change

  • Policy makers
  • Influential people in the community

___Interested members of the community at large

___Members of the organization itself

What do you have to do to get a participatory planning process up and running?

___You've identified all the individuals and groups who need to be involved

___You've gotten the message about the planning process out to everyone who needs to be informed

___You've chosen someone to convene the process

___You've held an initial meeting, for which:

  • You've personally invited as many people as possible
  • You've planned meeting times around the convenience of those attending, rather than the convenience of the organization
  • You've held the meeting in a place that's convenient and comfortable for everyone involved
  • You've provided some food and drink
  • You've considered carefully who'll run the meeting
  • If the community is multilingual, you've made sure to have translators present, or to present everything in multiple languages, so that everyone feels included
  • You've planned activities so that everyone at the meeting has a chance to be heard, either in the larger group or in a smaller one
  • By the end of the meeting, there was a clear next step, and everyone knew what it was

___You've chosen someone to guide the planning process

___You've decided who will approve a final plan

___You've decided how long the planning process will go on

Examples
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:51

Example: Participatory Planning in The Literacy Project

In 1995, the Massachusetts Department of Education offered a three-year grant to communities to try to reach and serve the families of children aged three and under. Their idea was that, by providing services to families and children at risk, communities might be able to head off some of the problems these children might have later, when they got to school. The Request for Proposals (RFP) had a number of requirements, a major one being an oversight board that included people from all elements of the community that might be involved with families - schools and day care providers, hospitals and other health agencies, human service providers, parents, municipal government, etc.

The largely rural western Massachusetts county of Hampshire also contains several colleges and the main campus of the state university. At the urging of its Human Service Coordinator, Hampshire County decided to apply as a county, and got permission to do so. This decision made the application process much more complicated, because the Director and the agency convening the process had to contact and involve the appropriate people from 20 or so towns scattered over several hundred square miles.

Less than 10 days after the RFP came out, I, as director of an adult literacy program that operated in Hampshire County, sat at a meeting with several school principals and counselors; three doctors; two hospital administrators; three parents; the directors of a day care center, a mental health agency, a battered women's shelter, an agency that operated homeless shelters, a pregnant-and-parenting teen program, an information and referral service, and an anti-poverty agency; and representatives from the Department of Social Services, the county welfare office, the Office for Children, the  Department of Developmental Services (DDS), and other state and local agencies; as well as the County Human Services Coordinator.

We spent two long but productive meetings thinking through and planning the grant proposal, which was then written by an administrator at the anti-poverty agency. Using ideas from nearly everyone in the group, the proposal, rather than concentrating on a specific program, envisioned an intervention that encompassed supporting parents in whatever ways they needed. It created a safety net for parents and children that stretched across the whole county, and included both specific and general services and activities. In short, it was an intervention designed for a whole county, rather than a single community, and one that recognized that the needs of parents in that county were varied and constantly changing.

Much to everyone's surprise, our proposal was one of only a small number funded across the state. Ours was the only proposal that aimed at more than a single community, but it had county-wide support, and everyone was committed to making it work. The group that had been assembled to write the proposal agreed to stay together and serve as the oversight board, and the information and referral center housed the program 's coordinator and served as a clearinghouse for issues related to the grant.

The grant program worked on two levels. On one level, it ran activities and programs in different areas of the county - often tied into the already-existing work of county agencies, schools, hospitals, and the like - geared to the needs of families with kids three and under. Some of the grant money was used for outreach to families, particularly those often underserved, to encourage their attendance. Activities and programs included a semi-annual vaccination celebration (a fair with clowns, refreshments, and entertainment at which kids could get both vaccinated and face-painted), and pre- and postnatal parenting classes at one of the hospitals.

The larger part of the grant, however, was directed toward meeting needs expressed directly by parents and providers, and toward creating and maintaining a flexible network of integrated services and support for families that could be activated when a need or a problem arose. A small amount of the grant was used, for instance, to run a "taxi service" of volunteer drivers who helped parents without transportation (remember, this is a rural area, where the nearest store or population center can be ten or more miles away) to get to appointments with the pediatrician or welfare office, to do shopping, or to pick up children from day care.

The board met officially four times a year, and small groups of it met far more often to work out the details of specific new or ongoing activities. More important, the organizations involved worked together far more and in a far more focused way to meet the needs of mutual participants, and to try to narrow in on issues pertaining to young children and their families.

A good example of how the grant worked at its best took place in my own adult literacy program. At one of the Hampshire County sites, a female learner had just had a baby, whom she often brought to class. The instructor, himself the father of two young children, was very concerned about the well-being of the child, who was being fed solids at two months, and who was often ignored for long periods of time. Ultimately, the instructor decided he had to intervene.

He had a conference with the mother, at which he explained that he was concerned for the child, and that he wanted her to get help if she was to continue to participate in the literacy program. Rather than simply leaving her on her own to find assistance, however, he was able to put her directly in touch with a pediatrician, a parenting program, WIC (child nutrition), transportation assistance, and other help, all of which he had arranged through connections set up by the grant. He accompanied her to some of the initial meetings, and "handed her off" to specific individuals who, he knew, would establish relationships with her and help her through the process of learning to take better care of herself and her child.

Far from being resentful, the woman welcomed the help, and the instructor almost immediately noticed a marked improvement in the way she dealt with her infant. Furthermore, both mother and child were now getting basic services - regular medical checkups, help with proper nutrition - that would go toward keeping them healthy over the long term. The lives of that mother and baby were, in some sense, saved by the safety net the grant had set in place. And the flexibility of that net had been made possible by the participatory planning process that had generated the original grant proposal.

The Department of Education had been profoundly dubious when Hampshire County had submitted a county-wide proposal, and had funded it, at least in part, just to see what would happen. The Hampshire County program was, in fact, one of the most successful in the state. The participation in the grant was real and ongoing, and - perhaps even more important - ultimately involved the people most concerned with the issue.

Although I continued, as director of my program to attend board meetings, I also made sure that the instructors who ran the Hampshire County sites of our program were involved, and that their voices were heard in planning and committee sessions. Other program directors did the same, so that by the time I left my program, two or three years later, most of the work of the grant program was being accomplished by community members and by the line staff of the organizations involved, rather than by administrators.

Contributor

Phil Rabinowitz

PowerPoint
Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:53

A PowerPoint presentation summarizing the major points in the section.

Section 3. Identifying Targets and Agents of Change: Who Can Benefit and Who Can Help
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:54
Main Section
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:54
  • Who are the people and partners involved in community change?

  • Who are the people and communities most directly affected by the problem or issue?

  • Who can help contribute to improvement?

  • What do partners in change do?

  • How to identify people most directly affected and partners in change

Who are the people and partners involved in community change?

When doing work in your community, the first thing to decide is what issue or problem you want to address. Whether you are teaching children to read or trying to create safer neighborhoods, it's your group's reason for being; it's what you're all about.

You and your organization are not alone. There are people who can benefit from an initiative and people who can contribute knowledge, experience, resources, and support. We need to be clear about who should benefit--youth and parents, for example--and who can help address the issue or problem--including youth, parents and guardians, teachers, service providers, and others. Knowing who these people are is an important step.

In this section, we'll help you identify the people and communities your organization or initiative is trying to reach and involve, as well as the people, organizations, and institutions that can help contribute to positive change. We'll also consider what these partners can do and how you can develop a plan to make sure you have included everyone who can benefit, contribute, or offer important perspectives--and not just the most obvious participants.

Sounds simple, doesn't it? It can be. It's a question of being clear, complete, and making sure you look at every angle.

Who are the people and communities most directly affected by the problem or issue?

You're probably trying to change a certain behavior, condition, or outcome, such as reducing harmful substance use or creating decent jobs. Sometimes, the issue you are addressing is clear; other times, the root causes are less obvious. Children falling asleep in class, for example, might be affected by not having had breakfast rather than by a problem in the school itself. Limited access to food, in turn, may be connected to a family experiencing poverty, inadequate job opportunities, transportation barriers, or other conditions. Talking with people who experience the issue can help you gain a better understanding of what conditions and behaviors contribute to the problem or issue.

Like identifying the root causes of a problem, understanding who is most directly affected and who should be involved can be relatively simple or more complex.

Generally, people connected to the issue will fall into two broad categories:

  • People who directly experience the problem or experience increased risk
  • People whose actions, decisions, policies, or practices influence the problem or its possible solutions

Identifying who directly experiences an issue may sometimes be straightforward. If you are trying to increase immunization among children under two years of age in an urban community, for example, those children, along with their parents or guardians and health care providers, may be among the people most directly connected to the effort. People who inject drugs are important partners in HIV prevention efforts because they may experience increased risk of HIV transmission and can provide essential knowledge about effective prevention strategies.

Sometimes, however, the people most directly affected aren't the same people whose actions or decisions need to change. In the immunization example above, children under two years of age can't immunize themselves. Parents and guardians, health care providers, health systems, and others who influence access to vaccination may therefore also need to be involved. In this case, the effort should consider people whose actions, decisions, or practices influence the issue.

Examples of these people include:

  • Peers
  • Parents and caregivers
  • Service providers
  • Teachers
  • Business owners and retailers (e.g., those who sell tobacco or alcohol)
  • Elected and appointed officials

As you work on an initiative, you will want to consider both people who directly experience the issue and people who can influence the conditions connected to it. Often, people with lived experience can also be important leaders and partners in creating solutions.

For example, a community initiative to improve public transportation might use:

  • A media campaign to increase public awareness of transportation challenges and engage people who would benefit from improved transportation
  • A letter-writing campaign directed at public officials who have influence over resource allocations for improved transportation

Who can help contribute to improvement?

Next, you'll want to identify potential partners in change. Who can influence the people, policies, systems, and conditions connected to the problem or issue? These are individuals or groups who can contribute knowledge, relationships, resources, leadership, or decision-making authority to help address issues that matter to your community.

Sometimes, partners in change are members of the same groups as the people most directly affected. You might concentrate part of your "Healthy Eating" campaign on high school science and health teachers, for example, so that they can share nutrition information with their students. In this instance, teachers may both participate in changes themselves and help support broader improvements. Similarly, people with lived experience of gang involvement may contribute to efforts to reduce gang-related violence; peers may influence the academic achievement of other youth; and people who have experienced trauma or loss may help others with similar experiences cope with the effects.

Remember that successful community change depends heavily on relationships and collaboration. Ideally, people experiencing the issue are deeply engaged as partners in change. Success is more likely when people spend time together, build trust, care about each other, and recognize each other's contributions. Teachers may be more effective partners when they have the support of parents, just as parents may be more effective when their efforts are supported by teachers.

What do partners in change do?

Partners in change can contribute in a variety of ways. If they are working closely with someone who is directly affected by the issue, they may do the following:

  • Establish a strong relationship with the person most affected. When people see someone as credible, trustworthy, and caring, they may feel more comfortable sharing their experiences, concerns, and ideas and working together toward change.
  • Understand the issue or problem. In the classic novel To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus Finch tells his young daughter she must walk around in other people's shoes if she really wants to understand them. A strong partner in change takes a similar approach. To support meaningful change, they need to understand the person's experiences, circumstances, strengths, and the conditions influencing the issue.
  • Support informed choices and opportunities for change. Partners can help people understand available options, identify their own goals, and recognize opportunities and resources that may help them move toward those goals. A mentor, for example, might encourage a student by helping them recognize their strengths, explore educational opportunities, and develop a plan for what they want to pursue after high school.
  • Help make change possible. Deciding to make a change is an important first step, but people may also need information, resources, encouragement, supportive policies, services, or other forms of assistance. Partners in change can help identify and provide the support needed to move from intention to action.
  • Help sustain change. Meaningful change often takes time and ongoing support. Whether someone is returning to school, reducing or stopping substance use, beginning a new job, or pursuing another goal, supportive relationships and access to resources can help them continue making progress.

How do you identify people most directly affected and partners in change?

So, the next question is: How can you identify everyone who can benefit, contribute, and help? A first step is to answer the following questions. Just for your use, you might want to grab a piece of paper and write down your answers. Often, the act of writing something works as a brainstorming technique, and you'll come up with more ideas than you thought possible. You might do this with other members of your group and with people who experience the issue; the more perspectives you include, the stronger your understanding is likely to be.

  • What is the problem or issue you are trying to address? What really contributes to it? As we mentioned above, you might want to talk with people who experience the issue or do research to better understand the root causes. You might also want to try the "But why" technique. This method examines a problem by asking what caused it. Each time an answer is given, a follow-up, "But why?" is asked.
  • Who might resist the changes you want to make, and why? This is probably information you will want to use later, but it may be helpful to understand these perspectives from the beginning.

Now, you're ready to identify the people most directly affected and the partners who may contribute to change. As you did before, write down and brainstorm answers to the following questions. When you're done, review your answers and identify the people and groups who should be involved.

For people and communities most directly affected:

  • Who is affected by the problem? Think carefully and go beyond the most obvious people. Consider who directly experiences the issue, whose decisions or circumstances influence it, and what broader conditions may be contributing. For example, if children are struggling in school, consider the perspectives of students, families, teachers, school leaders, community organizations, and public officials, as well as factors such as class size, transportation, access to resources, and opportunities for family engagement. Write down all of the answers that come up. You can always refine the list later.
  • Who has been previously affected by the problem? Should they still be supported or involved? For example, if you are running an immunization program for children under two, ask whether there are older children who did not receive vaccinations when they were younger and could be reached now.
  • Who are the peers of those affected? If you are focusing on youth violence, for example, you might include a broad range of young people in your action plan, not only those who have directly experienced or been involved in violence.

For partners in change:

  • Who has the ability or authority to help bring about change?
  • Who has the time, resources, knowledge, relationships, or desire to contribute to change?
  • Who might be able to make a difference if your initiative engages them as a partner?
  • Who has a relationship with the people most directly affected? Whom do community members trust? Who do they turn to for information, guidance, or support?
  • Think about people who have lived experience with the issue. They may be some of the strongest partners in change. For example, a person in recovery from a substance use disorder may be able to provide meaningful peer support to someone who is working toward recovery. They can draw on lived experience, understand many of the challenges involved, and offer support without judgment.

For both:

  • Have you thought about people from all parts of your community? Are there different community sectors (e.g., churches and faith communities; schools; businesses) that might become involved?
  • Who does your organization particularly want to reach or work with? With whom do you think you can be particularly effective? What relationships or contacts do you already have that could help?

In Summary

Identifying the people and communities most directly affected by an issue and the partners who can contribute to change is an important step in your planning process. It helps put the work in context and reminds you that community change is a shared effort. People who experience an issue are not simply recipients of programs or services; they may also bring important knowledge, lived experience, leadership, relationships, and ideas for solutions. By involving people who can both benefit and contribute, your initiative can develop approaches that are more responsive to the community and more likely to create meaningful and lasting change.

Contributor

Marcelo Vilela

Jenette Nagy

Stephen B. Fawcett

Resources

Print Resources

Fawcett, S., et al. (1996). Preventing child abuse and neglect: An action planning guide for building a caring community. Lawrence, KS: Work Group on Health Promotion and Community Development, University of Kansas.

Green, L., & Kreuter, M. (1991). Health promotion planning. Mayfield Publishing Company.

Rogers, E. (1983). Diffusion of innovations (3rd Ed.). New York, NY: Freepress.

Watzlawick, P., et al. (1974). Change: Principles of problem formation and problem resolution. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Co., Inc.

Checklist
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:55

___You understand that targets of change are people who experience the problem or issue or are directly at risk and who contribute to the problem through their actions or inactions

___You understand that agents of change are those who can influence the people and conditions that contribute to the problem or issue

___You understand that targets and agents of change may be the same people

You know what agents of change do:

___They establish strong relationships with the people most affected

___They diagnose the issue or problem

___They convince the people experiencing the issue of the need for (and the possibility of) a change

___They help make that change happen

___They help maintain that change

You know how to identify targets and agents of change:

___You know the problem or issue you want to address

___You know who might resist the changes you want to make

For targets of change:

___You know who is affected by the problem

___You know who has previously been affected by the problem

___You know who the peers of those affected are

For agents of change:

___You know who has the power to bring about change

___You know who has the time, resources, and desire to bring about change

___You know who might be able to do it, if your organization can convince them

___You know who already has a relationship with your targets of change

___You have considered people who were (or are) targets

For both:

___You have thought about people from all parts of your community

___You have considered those your organization particularly wants to target or work with

Examples
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:55

Example: Targets and agents of change for child abuse prevention program

Below is a filled out example of a planning sheet that can be used to help determine the targets and agents of change for your initiative. In the Tools section, you'll find a blank copy you can print out and use for your organization.

What behaviors and conditions contribute to the issue or problem?

Who are the people who experience or contribute to the issue?

(Targets of Change)

Who are the people who can contribute to improvement?

(Agents of Change)

  • Poverty / economic stress
  • Poor anger management skills
  • Substance use
  • Lack of parenting skills
  • Family history of abuse
  • Parents and guardians
  • Relatives
  • Teachers
  • Ministers
  • Neighbors
  • Parents and Guardians
  • Relatives
  • Service providers

 

Tools
mloewenstein Thu, 01/03/2013 - 11:47

Tool: Planning Sheet

Fill out the following sheet as part of your planning process. You can use the information to decide who can benefit and contribute when you write or revise your action plan.

Planning Sheet: Connecting targets and agents of change

Community issue or problem: ____________________________________________________

What behaviors and conditions contribute to the issue or problem?

Who are the people who experience or contribute to the issue?

(Targets of Change)

Who are the people who can contribute to improvement?

(Agents of Change)

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

PowerPoint
Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:56

A PowerPoint presentation summarizing the major points in the section.

Section 4. Using Community Sectors to Reach Targets and Agents of Change
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:57
Main Section
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:57

An outreach worker, hired to help establish an English language learning program in a community with a large Portuguese-speaking population, was having difficulty connecting with potential participants. Partially because of language differences and partially because he was new to the community, his early outreach efforts had limited success. He knew he needed help from people who already had trusted relationships within the community.

The outreach worker decided to contact leaders from two important community institutions: a local soccer club and a Catholic church. The director of the soccer club and the priest both recognized a need for English language learning opportunities and agreed to help organize an informational meeting.

The priest shared information about the program with members of the congregation and invited people to attend the meeting. The director of the soccer club personally invited community members who might be interested and introduced the outreach worker at the club, where he was able to talk informally with potential participants and learn more about their interests and needs.

By the time of the meeting, word had spread through the community, and the hall was full. More than 40 people signed up for classes, and many said they would share information with friends and family. When classes began several weeks later, they were well attended from the start.

This story is an example of working through community sectors – in this case, faith and cultural/recreational networks – to connect with people through trusted relationships. We'll briefly examine who should be involved in community change and then explore how community sectors can help you reach, engage, and collaborate with people throughout the community.

What do we mean by community sectors?

“Community sectors” can mean a number of different things. In some cases, it describes broad categories – the public and private sectors, for example, referring respectively to government-related organizations and those outside government. Sometimes, the term “community sector” refers to community-based organizations, institutions, and initiatives, as distinguished from those operated by state or national governments, large corporations, or international organizations.

In this section, when we refer to “community sectors,” we’re pointing to the various groups, institutions, networks, and areas of community life that people may be connected to through common social, political, economic, cultural, professional, or religious interests. In some cases, membership in a sector may be obvious or intentional (business owners as part of the “business sector,” for example). In others, people may not think of themselves in those terms (parents may not think of themselves as part of the “education sector”). Many individuals may belong to, or have contact with, several sectors.

So what are these sectors? We’d be hard pressed to name all the sectors that exist in every community, but there are numerous categories that are common across many communities:

  • Health. This includes medical and mental health professionals (physicians, nurses, psychologists, therapists, physical therapists, etc.), pharmacists and pharmacies, hospitals and other inpatient facilities, clinics, complementary health practitioners, community health workers, and public health agencies and systems.
  • Education. Public and private K-12 schools, early childhood programs, colleges and universities, school boards, school administrators, teachers, other educational staff, parents and caregivers, students, state boards of education, adult education programs, and English language learning programs.
  • Law and justice. Local and state law enforcement agencies, courts, judges, probation and parole officers, prosecutors, public defenders, legal aid organizations, restorative justice programs, and other justice-system partners.
  • Government. Regional, provincial, state, local, and tribal governments, agencies, departments, and officials, both elected and appointed.
  • Business. This sector can range from self-employed workers and locally owned small businesses to large employers and multinational corporations with a local presence.
  • Youth. Young people themselves and the organizations, programs, schools, clubs, mentors, and other adults who work directly with them. There may be considerable overlap with education, families, human services, culture, and sports and recreation.
  • Families and caregivers. Whether families and caregivers are viewed as a separate community sector may depend on the issue. They may be particularly important in efforts involving children, young people, older adults, people with disabilities, or others who receive family or caregiving support.
  • Media and communications. This may include newspapers, magazines, radio, television, online news organizations, podcasts, social media platforms, community newsletters, content creators, and other communication channels.
  • Human services. This sector generally includes nonprofit, public, and volunteer organizations that provide services such as workforce development, food assistance, housing support, older adult services, adult education, disability services, immigrant and refugee support, advocacy, and other community resources.
  • Faith communities. Places of worship, faith leaders, members, and religious or spiritually based organizations representing the traditions present in the community.
  • Service and membership organizations. Local, national, and international service organizations, professional associations, fraternities and sororities, veterans’ organizations, social clubs, and other membership-based groups.
  • Community advocacy and volunteer groups. These might focus on public policy, support for local institutions, economic development, neighborhood improvement, environmental issues, community events, or other priorities identified by community members.
  • Arts and culture. This sector includes musicians, dancers, writers, actors, designers, visual artists, cultural organizations, theaters, museums, galleries, arts educators, production staff, and community members who participate in or support the arts.
  • Housing and development. This sector may include public and nonprofit housing organizations, tenant organizations, housing advocates, property owners and managers, developers, planners, affordable housing providers, and others involved in residential and commercial development.
  • Sports and recreation. This sector might include sports clubs, recreation departments, amateur and professional athletic organizations, public and private recreation facilities, gyms, coaches, personal trainers, recreation leaders, camp staff, athletes, spectators, and supporters.
  • Environment and natural resources. This sector may include environmental organizations, conservation groups, land trusts, farmers, hunters and anglers, outdoor recreation groups, scientists, environmental justice organizations, Indigenous communities, natural-resource professionals, and businesses whose work depends on healthy ecosystems.

A conservation land trust is an organization that protects land for conservation, recreation, agriculture, habitat, or other community purposes. It may purchase land directly or work with landowners to establish conservation agreements that limit future development while allowing the land to remain privately owned.

  • Agriculture and food systems. This sector can include small and large farms, ranchers, agricultural workers, cooperatives, food processors, distributors, farmers markets, community gardens, food businesses, agricultural organizations, and consumers.

There can be, as we’ve discussed, a large amount of overlap among sectors. Furthermore, the list above is far from complete: a given community may have additional sectors because of its particular history, economy, geography, or culture. A community whose economy is largely agricultural, for instance, may have distinct dairy, grain, fruit-growing, or livestock networks. A culturally and linguistically diverse community may also have organizations and networks connected to particular racial, ethnic, cultural, immigrant, refugee, or language communities.

Sectors exist because of common interests, relationships, experiences, identities, or responsibilities shared by their members. As a result, they can be useful for building relationships and connecting with people who may want to participate in or contribute to a community effort.

Who are the people and partners involved in community change?

People and communities most directly affected

People and communities most directly affected include those who experience an issue, are affected by related policies or conditions, or stand to benefit from an effort. They may also be important leaders, decision-makers, advocates, and partners in creating solutions.

In some cases, an effort may focus partly on individual behaviors – such as supporting people who want to stop smoking or helping people manage chronic health conditions. In other cases, the most important changes may involve organizations, policies, services, systems, or environmental conditions rather than individual behavior.

Examples of people or groups who may be directly affected include:

  • People managing health conditions who may benefit from supportive services, accessible health care, healthy environments, or changes they choose to make in their daily routines.
  • People who use products associated with health risks, such as tobacco or alcohol, and communities affected by how those products are marketed or sold.
  • People with substance use disorders or people seeking recovery support.
  • Young people affected by or involved in community violence.
  • People seeking employment or experiencing barriers to employment.
  • People seeking literacy, digital skills, workforce skills, or instruction in a community’s primary language.
  • People who are incarcerated or returning to the community after incarceration.
  • People experiencing homelessness or housing instability.
  • Farmers and agricultural communities seeking environmentally and economically sustainable practices.
  • Individuals, businesses, or industries whose practices contribute to pollution and who can help reduce environmental harm.
  • Developers and housing partners who can contribute to affordable, accessible, and environmentally responsible development.

Developers may also be important partners when an effort seeks to change policies, incentives, regulations, or development practices to encourage community-responsive practices.

  • Legislators and other policymakers, such as school boards, boards of health, and regulatory agencies, whose decisions can influence discrimination, food access, neighborhood investment, workplace safety, worker protections, education, transportation, housing, health, and other community conditions.
  • Media and communications organizations, which can help explain issues, share community perspectives, and increase public awareness.

Other people and communities may benefit from changes without necessarily needing to change their own behavior. Examples include:

  • People and families seeking affordable, stable housing
  • Students attending schools with limited resources or inadequate facilities
  • Individuals or communities affected by social, economic, or political discrimination
  • People with disabilities
  • Individuals or communities without reliable access to clean drinking water or sanitation
  • Communities with limited access to health care
  • People experiencing food insecurity or malnutrition
  • People and communities exposed to environmental hazards or pollution
  • Workers exposed to hazardous substances or unsafe workplace conditions

People most directly affected by an issue should not be viewed only as beneficiaries of an intervention. They may also have essential knowledge, lived experience, leadership, and ideas about solutions. Community efforts are often stronger when people most affected have meaningful opportunities to identify priorities, shape strategies, advocate for change, and participate in implementation and evaluation.

Partners in change

Partners in change are people, organizations, institutions, and networks that can help create positive change. They may contribute lived experience, relationships, decision-making authority, expertise, resources, advocacy, services, or community leadership.

In many cases, people most directly affected by an issue and partners in change are the same people. For example, residents affected by housing affordability may also be advocates, organizers, advisory-board members, or leaders working to change housing policy.

Partners in change may also include public officials, media organizations, families, educators, health professionals, businesses, community organizations, and others whose participation can strengthen an effort.

Some common partners in change include:

  • Legislators and other public officials
  • Media and communications organizations
  • Health care professionals, community health workers, and health administrators
  • Teachers, educators, and school counselors
  • Parents, caregivers, and other family members
  • Peers
  • People whose lived experience provides valuable knowledge and credibility, such as people with experience in violence-prevention efforts, recovery from substance use disorders, homelessness, disability advocacy, or other community issues
  • Business owners, employers, and organizational leaders
  • Community leaders – including people with formal leadership roles and those who are trusted because of their experience, relationships, fairness, knowledge, or service to the community

Sometimes an entire sector may be important to involve. The health sector, for example, can be an important partner when efforts seek to improve health systems, public health policy, health equity, or other community conditions.

Why use community sectors to reach and engage people and partners?

Community sectors can help you connect with people through organizations, relationships, and networks they already know and trust. They can also help broaden participation and bring additional knowledge and resources into an effort. Some reasons for working through community sectors include:

  • To connect with people who may face barriers to participation. Some people may have limited contact with formal organizations because of language, transportation, accessibility, past experiences, work schedules, immigration concerns, geographic isolation, or other barriers. Trusted community organizations, cultural groups, faith communities, neighborhood networks, and other partners may help create more accessible and comfortable ways to participate.
  • To ensure representation from across the community. It is important to include people who will implement, experience, or be affected by an effort. Working through different community sectors can help bring a broader range of perspectives into planning, implementation, and evaluation.
  • To build trust. Community sectors can connect your effort with trusted people and organizations. These relationships can provide a foundation for long-term collaboration and can also strengthen trust among sectors that may not have worked together before.
  • To draw on knowledge from different parts of the community. People in different sectors may bring knowledge of community history, previous efforts, relationships, strengths, priorities, barriers, and potential areas of conflict. This knowledge can strengthen planning and implementation.
  • To bring sectors together. Different sectors may have limited opportunities to communicate or collaborate. Bringing them into the same effort can help build relationships and lay the groundwork for future collaboration.
  • To raise awareness of the issue throughout the community. Community sectors often have established ways of communicating with members and partners. These networks can help share accurate information and community perspectives.
  • To build broad community support. When people and organizations from different sectors participate meaningfully in an effort, they can share information through their own networks, encourage others to participate, and strengthen community ownership.

How do you use community sectors to reach and engage people and partners?

Working through community sectors is often easier when you already have relationships in the sectors you hope to involve. If you don’t, this may be a good opportunity to begin building them. The following steps can help you identify and engage the people and partners who should be involved.

Determine whom you need to reach and engage

This first step is closely connected to your strategy. What changes are you hoping to support, and who should be involved in making them happen? If you’re starting an advocacy campaign, you may want to engage policymakers as well as people directly affected by the issue. If you’re providing a service, you’ll want to connect with potential participants and the people or organizations they trust. If you’re trying to increase public awareness, you may want to involve media and communications partners.

In many cases, you’ll need to engage several different individuals and groups. An advocacy effort might involve legislators as well as community members with lived experience of the issue. Their stories, knowledge, and perspectives can help policymakers and the broader public understand why change matters. In recruiting participants for a service, you might also work with educators, families, community organizations, faith communities, or others who already have trusted relationships with potential participants.

What do you mean by “reach and engage?”

Different efforts have different goals for communication and engagement. Among the most common are:

  • Share information. You may simply want people to know about an issue, resource, opportunity, or service.
  • Encourage a specific action, such as attending a meeting, completing a survey, contacting a public official, accessing a service, or participating in a community activity.
  • Support healthier or safer choices. For example, a tobacco-prevention campaign might provide young people with information about nicotine addiction, industry marketing practices, health effects, and resources for quitting.
  • Invite people to an event, such as a vaccination clinic, job fair, community forum, workshop, or advocacy event.
  • Connect people with a service or resource, such as workforce development, mental health services, a domestic violence program, housing services, food assistance, adult education, or community arts programming.
  • Invite volunteers or community partners to participate in events, programs, outreach, planning, or other activities.
  • Build public support for an event, program, initiative, or policy proposal.
  • Engage in advocacy or influence policy. This may involve meeting directly with policymakers, sharing community perspectives, building coalitions, using media, or mobilizing public participation.

Reaching and engaging people can therefore involve much more than simply spreading information. It may include relationship building, listening, personal invitations, community conversations, partnerships, and creating meaningful opportunities for participation.

Decide what sectors might need to be involved to reach the desired group(s)

You might have to do some research here. Remember the importance of the soccer club and church to the Portuguese-speaking community in the introduction to this section? What organizations, networks, institutions, or groups are important to the people you hope to engage? Whom do they trust? Where do they get information? Where do they already gather or participate?

One group might be best connected through faith communities, another through schools, neighborhood organizations, cultural organizations, social media networks, or trusted community leaders. Public officials may be reached through professional relationships, community organizations, constituents, advocacy groups, or other networks.

Other sectors that might help are those people interact with regularly – businesses, community organizations, media outlets, schools, health care providers, libraries, recreation programs, and others. If these partners can share your information or help facilitate participation through their regular activities, they may help broaden your reach.

Determine who in a given sector is the best contact, and establish that contact

Using community sectors effectively depends on understanding which people and organizations are trusted and credible within a particular community. The fact that an organization serves a population does not necessarily mean that everyone in that population trusts it. In many cases, individual staff members, community leaders, peer advocates, or other trusted messengers may have especially strong relationships.

This is where existing relationships can be valuable. If your current contact isn’t the best person to connect with the community you hope to engage, they may be able to suggest someone else and provide an introduction. If you don’t already have contacts, take time to begin building relationships.

Making contacts in various community sectors

Personal introductions can be helpful when building new relationships. If you don’t know anyone in a sector who can help you get started, ask colleagues, community members, participants, or partners whether they know someone who would be appropriate to contact.

If a personal introduction isn’t possible, reach out using the communication method that is most appropriate for the person or organization. This might be email, phone, social media, an online contact form, or an in-person conversation. Briefly introduce yourself, explain why you are reaching out, and be clear about what you hope to discuss.

If you have no connection at all, you may need to contact several people before finding the right person. Community directories, organizational websites, social media, local events, and recommendations from other partners can help identify potential contacts.

A good starting point is often someone who knows many of the people or organizations you hope to involve. Depending on the community and issue, that might be a community organizer, cultural organization leader, faith leader, neighborhood association representative, librarian, Chamber of Commerce staff member, health care professional, school staff member, or public official.

There is no single best communication method for every community or sector. Some people prefer email, others phone calls, text messages, social media, scheduled meetings, or in-person conversations. When possible, use the communication methods people themselves prefer and make it easy for them to respond.

Clarify what you’re asking for

Why do you want to connect with people? What are you asking them to do? These are questions most people will want answered when you contact them. Be prepared to briefly explain your organization or effort, what you hope to accomplish, why you believe their perspective or participation matters, and what you are asking from them.

Whatever the answers are, they should be clear, complete, and accurate. Be transparent about the time, responsibilities, decisions, or resources involved. People should be able to make an informed choice about whether and how they want to participate.

Be creative

There are many ways to use community sectors to connect with people. We’ve largely focused on relationship-based approaches through individuals and institutions, but communication can also be built into places and activities people already use. For example, pharmacies might share information about a community blood-pressure program, libraries might promote adult learning opportunities, or arts organizations might share information about a local initiative in their programs and newsletters.

Use media and communication channels people already use

Media and communications cut across nearly every community sector. Depending on whom you are trying to reach, you might use local news outlets, community newsletters, social media, podcasts, streaming platforms, text-message networks, radio, television, community websites, or other channels. The key is to use communication channels that the people you hope to engage actually use and trust.

Another important network is made up of people already involved in your effort as participants, partners, volunteers, advisors, or community leaders. Ask them whether they can help connect with others who may want to participate. People already engaged in an effort can often be effective ambassadors because they can describe their own experiences and explain why participation matters.

These relationships can help your effort grow through existing community networks while also strengthening connections across sectors.

Keep at it

Engaging the first few participants or partners doesn’t mean your work is done. Programs and services may need ongoing outreach to remain accessible and responsive to the community. Advocacy efforts often require long-term relationship building and sustained participation. Continue listening, communicating, inviting new perspectives, and strengthening partnerships throughout the life of the effort.

In Summary

Whether your goal is to share information, provide a service, run a program or initiative, improve environmental or social conditions, or pursue advocacy, you’ll need to connect with people and organizations throughout the community. One way to do that is through community sectors – the groups, institutions, networks, and areas of community life connected by common interests, responsibilities, relationships, identities, or purposes.

The business sector, health sector, education sector, government sector, faith communities, cultural organizations, community-based organizations, and many other sectors can all contribute different relationships, knowledge, perspectives, and resources.

In general, people are more likely to participate when information and invitations come through sources they know and trust. By building relationships across community sectors, listening to community members, and working with trusted partners, you can broaden participation, strengthen collaboration, and create community efforts that are more responsive, inclusive, and sustainable.

Contributor

Phil Rabinowitz

Resources

Online Resources

The Global Health Politics Podcast, Season 3, Episode 5, features Monica Wang discussing The Collective Cure, a community-driven approach to addressing health inequities through collective action, relationship-building, and systems change.

Checklist
mloewenstein Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:58

What do we mean by community sectors?

___Community sectors are the various groups that people in the larger community might be divided into for reasons of common social, political, economic, cultural, or religious interests

___Membership in sectors often overlaps

___Different communities may contain sectors specific to those types of communities

___Sectors that exist in many or most communities include:

  • Health
  • Education
  • Law enforcement
  • Government
  • Business
  • Youth
  • Parents
  • The media
  • Human services
  • Religion
  • Service/fraternal organizations
  • Community activist and volunteer groups
  • Arts and culture
  • Housing and development
  • Sports and recreation
  • The environment
  • Agriculture

Who are the targets and agents of change?

___Targets of change are either those whose behavior you want to change or those who stand to benefit from the changes your effort aims to bring about

__ Primary targets of change are those whose behavior you’re trying to change directly

___Secondary targets of change are those who stand to benefit from changes in others’ behavior or in circumstances, rather than from changes in their own behavior

___Agents of change are those – policy makers, for example – who can help to bring change about

___Agents of change are often primary targets of change as well, especially in advocacy efforts

Why use community sectors to reach targets and agents of change?

___To reach hard-to-contact populations

___To ensure representation from all sectors of the community

___To build trust

___To take advantage of the knowledge of people in different sectors

___To bring sectors together

___To raise awareness of the issue throughout the community

___To gain widespread community support

How do you use community sectors to reach targets and agents of change?

___Determine whom you need to reach

___Decide what sectors might be needed to reach the desired group(s)

___Determine who in a given sector is the best contact, and establish that contact

___Clarify what you’re asking for

___Be creative

___Use the media to reach people through the channels they normally pay attention to

___Keep at it

PowerPoint
Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 12/11/2012 - 16:58

A PowerPoint presentation summarizing the major points in the section.

https://ctb.ku.edu/en/table-of-contents/analyze/where-to-start
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
© 1994-2026 The University of Kansas. All Rights Reserved.