Chapter 17. | Section 3. Print

Section 3. Defining and Analyzing the Problem

Choosing which problem to solve

A small, rural substance use prevention group is trying to decide where to focus their youth related efforts. In the following chart, the group compared two problems to see which one is more important to the group.

  Problem 1: Many underage teens smoke cigarettes or chew tobacco Problem 2: Many teenagers use illegal drugs (marijuana, cocaine, et cetera)
How frequently does the problem occur? Very Frequently Frequently
How many people are affected?

Most area high school students have smoked at least once; a significant percentage smoke regularly

In our rural community, few illicit drugs are available; this is a fairly small number
For what amount of time are they affected?

Regular smokers, often for life

Often life-long consequences
How severe is the effect?

Relatively severe

Can be tremendously severe

How important do group members perceive the problem to be? Very Important Less Important
How important is the problem perceived to be by others? Less important; smoking and chewing are widely accepted here Very Important
How likely is it that we can solve/significantly improve the problem? Very Likely Possible, but difficult
Are there any negative impacts? None None

Which problem will the coalition choose? That remains to be seen; this chart won't give a magic answer. But by using this or a similar device, it's easy to see all of the different aspects of the problem, and the group is now better equipped to make an informed choice.

Rob’s Barbershop Community Foundation: Using Problem Analysis to Match Hair-Care Access Solutions to Local Barriers

Founded in 2000, Rob’s Barbershop Community Foundation (RBCF) works to reduce barriers to regular hair care among individuals facing economic, transportation, knowledge, or access challenges. Through partnerships with schools and community organizations, RBCF provides technical assistance and connects participants with no-cost hair-care services and instruction.
Rather than beginning with a predetermined program, RBCF first assesses the problem at each partner site. Using a 29-question assessment, the organization identifies the population affected, examines the causes of limited hair-care access, prioritizes key barriers, and evaluates the partner’s capacity to respond. Only after completing this analysis does RBCF select one or more intervention strategies, which may include a permanent onsite salon, a portable pop-up salon, case management services, or connections with hair-care professionals through its Hair Pair platform. The following examples illustrate how this process guided intervention selection in two schools.
At Arundel High School in Gambrills, Maryland, the assessment identified approximately 150 students facing barriers to regular hair care. The assessment identified limited hair-care knowledge and skills among some students and caregivers, insufficient household income, transportation challenges, and limited access to local providers as the primary barriers. The assessment also revealed that the school had unused classroom space but lacked the funding, specialized expertise, and staff capacity necessary to operate hair-care services independently.
Based on these findings, RBCF determined that a combination of approaches would best address the problem. The organization converted the available classroom into a full-service barber and beauty salon and provided onsite case management to coordinate student referrals, outreach, and appointments. This solution addressed multiple root causes simultaneously by reducing transportation and cost barriers while increasing access to services and education.
At Annapolis Elementary School in Annapolis, Maryland, the assessment identified 40 students facing barriers to regular hair care. Staff ranked insufficient household income, transportation challenges, and limited hair-care knowledge and skills among the most significant barriers. The school also lacked both a dedicated space and the capacity to support a permanent salon. In response, RBCF deployed a portable pop-up salon consisting of a full-service, 10-chair setup that could be assembled in available spaces such as a gymnasium, hallway, or meeting room and stored between service dates. This approach allowed the school to provide no-cost, onsite hair-care services without requiring permanent space, additional staffing, or transportation to outside providers.
These examples illustrate how problem analysis can guide action. Although both schools faced limited access to regular hair care, differences in priority barriers, available resources, and organizational capacity led to different intervention strategies. By identifying root causes and assessing local conditions before selecting an intervention, RBCF tailors its response to each community’s needs rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach.
 

Contributor

Jenette Nagy