Tool 1: Deciding on a problem statement This exercise is adapted from an exercise on developing vision statements created by Lori Alvarado, DCCCA Center, Lawrence, KS. This activity works best in groups with less that 40 people. Ask everyone present at the meeting to write down his/her definition of the problem. Ask people to pair off and share their problem statements with each other. Together, the pair can create a new problem statement, incorporating ideas from both. Ask pairs to join together in groups of four, and again merge the statements into one. Continue joining the groups in larger and larger groups until everyone is together again, and you have one agreed upon statement. Tool 2: Choosing which problem to solve The following table can be used or adapted to help you decide which problem you want to try to solve if you have several on your plate at the same time. By answering each question, you can get a clearer idea of all of the aspects of solving a problem, and should be able to choose more easily and effectively. For a completed example of this chart, see the example below. Problem 1 Problem 2 How frequently does the problem occur? How many people are affected? For what amount of time are they affected? How severe is the effect? How important do group members perceive the problem to be? How important is the problem perceived to be by others? How likely is it that we can solve/significantly improve the problem? Are there any negative impacts? Choosing which problem to solve: Example A small, rural substance use prevention group is trying to decide where to focus their youth-related efforts. In the following chart, the group compared two problems to see which one is more important to the group. Problem 1: Many underage teens smoke cigarettes or chew tobacco Problem 2: Many teenagers use illegal drugs (marijuana, cocaine, et cetera) How frequently does the problem occur? Very Frequently Frequently How many people are affected? Most area high school students have smoked at least once; a significant percentage smoke regularly In our rural community, few illicit drugs are available; this is a fairly small number For what amount of time are they affected? Regular smokers, often for life Often life-long consequences How severe is the effect? Relatively severe Can be tremendously severe How important do group members perceive the problem to be? Very Important Less Important How important is the problem perceived to be by others? Less important; smoking and chewing are widely accepted here Very Important How likely is it that we can solve/significantly improve the problem? Very Likely Possible, but difficult Are there any negative impacts? None None Which problem will the coalition choose? That remains to be seen; this chart won't give a magic answer. But by using this or a similar device, it's easy to see all of the different aspects of the problem, and the group is now better equipped to make an informed choice. Contributor Jenette Nagy